News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by rayiner on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:25PM (#11844472)
Kind of a weird criticism to level at Matt Damon. Whether you agree with his politics or not, he's clearly extremely smart. He dropped out of Harvard and wrote an Oscar-winning movie script. He talks about theories with professors and hangs out with the President.
Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by scintill76 on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:09AM (#11844598)
> He talks about theories with professors and hangs out with the President.

These sound so superficially-smart that I'm almost wondering if you're joking. Every college student "talks about theories with professors", so does Matt Damon actually teach them something or show greater-than-average understanding? And the President is basically just another celebrity in this context, unless you tell us something meaningful Mr. Damon did with the President other than "hang out".

I'll grant you Damon is more articulate than many celebrities, but I've decided that by listening to what he says, not noting that professors and the President have occasionally been in his presence.

(P.S. Perhaps this is a disproportionate fixation on the closing sentence to some other points I agree with.)

Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by rayiner on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:15AM (#11844620)
Few people continue to show enough intellectual curiosity to discuss theories with professors long after they've dropped out of college. And the President is not "just another celebrity in this context." By virtue of his office, the President has enormous insight into various global problems, and Damon mentioned discussing those issues with him.
Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by scintill76 on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:53AM (#11844736)
OK, when has Damon met with professors, and what did they talk about? My Googling shows he talked to two professors at Harvard about the script of Good Will Hunting. They influenced his choice to make Will a math genius rather than physics, and maybe a few other points in the story (not really elaborated on here[1]). Damon's mother also happens to be a professor. Neither of these really qualify as talking about theories, or purely to satisfy his intellectual curiosity rather than to help in his non-academic work or incidental contact.

Again from some quick Googling, this seems an exemplary quote from Damon about what he would talk with President Obama about: "There are a lot of things that I really question — the legality of the drone strikes, these NSA revelations. Jimmy Carter came out and said we don’t live in a democracy. That’s a little intense when an ex-president says that. So you now, he’s got some explaining to do, particularly for a constitutional law professor." [2] I see no evidence to suggest that the President has deliberately chosen to speak with Damon about these issues because he especially values his opinion or considers him smart, or that Damon has any particular things to say beyond what any of the somewhat articulate among us here on HN could have said on those issues, or that anything Damon said caused the President to expand his knowledge which is, as you said, founded on responsibilities and insights that Damon can't possibly have.

In other words, any of us could do something notable but in a non-political field, be invited to a small-audience event with the President, have the opportunity to bring up some issues with him for 2 minutes, and honestly say that we'd "discussed issues with the President" like Damon can say, but it wouldn't be proof of much, other than that you're smart enough or maybe just lucky enough in one field to get the attention of the President's staff and be invited to an event that incidentally allowed you to chat with him. Also, if the press cared to report your brief accounts of it as widely as they did for Damon, it probably has more to do with you being a charismatic celebrity that people want to hear about, than with having a notable intellect that people want to learn from.

[1] http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0119217/trivia?item=tr0776622 [2] http://www.politico.com/blogs/click/2013/08/matt-damon-obama...

Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by hoodoof on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:39PM (#11844501)
Maybe it's a weird criticism because it isn't. How do you read my observation as criticism?
Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by scottLobster on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:09AM (#11844596)
You really want it broken down? The story is about a celebrity giving a commencement speech at MIT. You then make a provocative observation that celebrities are "held in the highest esteem above all categories of occupation". Which is a clear over-generalization meant to spark conversation on the topic. The most likely trajectory (by far) of any conversation that would be spawned from such a statement would be the traditional criticism: "why do we listen to celebrities so much when they usually don't know what they're talking about?". Hence the inference is that you're trying to criticize Matt Damon's speech.

Put more succinctly, the nature of the conversation a person is trying to start is typically a strong indicator of their perspective.

Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by colordrops on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:11AM (#11844601)
You have plausible deniability here, but would you say the same if this were a physicist or philanthropist or tech CEO? Can you explain what your meaning is in point out your observation? There are thousands of details we could have noticed about this commencement speech. Why was that the one thing you point out?
Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by enraged_camel on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:50PM (#11844536)
It definitely reads as veiled criticism, yes.
Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by hoodoof on Monday June 06, 2016 @12:26AM (#11844651)
OK well give your responses and time to think about it, yes I suppose in the back of my head I am thinking "what the?".

If I was at MIT I would want the speech to be from someone respected for their achievement in the world of intellectual endeavor.

It feels like it cheapens the institution to bring in an actor.

Now I will say I like Matt Damon's acting, and as far as Hollywood stars go, he comes across to me as if not the smartest, then one of the smartest, and that is certainly something to offset the cheapening of the MIT address.

My original observation remains the same though - actors are at the top of our society in terms of the amount of attention and adoration given by the community, sports stars a close second.

And may I say "The Martian" ..... well no-one does onscreen intellect/science like Matt Damon. What a great movie.

I think maybe somewhere deep down the thing that bothers me about this is that MIT is saying in an indirect way "if you can act really smart then you are on equal footing with people who are really smart". i.e. we value "the appearance of smart".

Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by ScottBurson on Monday June 06, 2016 @02:56AM (#11845099)
As an MIT alumnus, I think this is an excellent commencement speech.

Broadly, though, you're right -- we Americans do love our screen stars.

Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by pen2l on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:05PM (#11848291)
It's also worth noting that he most likely didn't quite right the speech. He had helpers write the speech. Everyone gets helpers to write/help write speeches.

My favorite example is Steve Jobs calling a lot of people to get help on writing the commencement speech from folks like Aaron Sorkin and others (yes, the same Sorkin that made the Steve Jobs movie which framed him not an entirely positive light).

Re:Matt Damon's Commencement Address at MIT by enraged_camel on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:31AM (#11844848)
He dropped out of Harvard and wrote an Oscar-winning movie script. I'd say that's quite an "intellectual" achievement.