They went through the process of specifying and developing a automated utility that downloads files, parses manifests and then acts accordingly to install BIOS or other updates, tested it and bundled it with their retail system build, and after all that effort didn't take the one tiny step to sign their files or at least put a $10 TLS certificated on their servers?
To me the more likely answer is that (as observed) this dates back to XP days or even earlier, when securing this sort of stuff was not front-of-mind. Back then, finding downloadable software served over https was rare. ftp or http was far more likely. And I think ASUS just never thought about updating their tools. They worked, so never really got a thorough second look at any point up until today.
I don't deny the possibility that adding TLS to the update mechanisms might make the world better. On the other hand, I haven't seen a business case that shows a clear benefit for company's like ASUS to change all the moving parts in their logistics chain. Admittedly, I haven't looked very hard.
Security risks are harder to quantify for the bottom line.
It also encourages reducing effort spent in fixing bugs before release, which is why I absolutely loathe this "update culture": the "we can always fix it sometime later" mentality is like procrastination, and leads to barely-working products being released.
It is true that before easy field-updateability, products did ship with unfixable bugs, but I feel like it has only gotten worse from there.
It's a shame because they make really good hardware.
Insecure automatic updates need to be met with automatic, unappealable per-day fines calibrated to gobble the margin this kind of behavior creates.
Which might be better, but consequences of actions and all that.
That’s the advantage of using the business line of products: it’s usually not as fucked up.
BestBuy doesn't care if it stocks ASUS or not. It cares about sales and margins. If there's an extra dollar putting Gateway on the shelf instead of ASUS they will. And their customers won't care. "BIOS updates with TLS!" stickers aren't going to improve sales.
Buying a laptop creates a consumer not a customer relationship. I want to pay the least, the manufacturer wants to deliver the least. A few years out, shiny-low-cost will drive my next purchase more than brand loyalty.