News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:On the Left by chroma on Sunday June 05, 2016 @06:34AM (#11840350)
That sort of baiting isn't necessary. I don't agree with Tim Bray, but I'm pretty damn sure he doesn't want to cause mass death. He simply thinks that his proposals would improve most people's wealth and well-being. At the very worst he's misguided, not malicious.
Re:On the Left by mafribe on Sunday June 05, 2016 @06:53AM (#11840392)
You are reducing a social problem to the question of individual intentions. Why is this an interesting option? Presumably nobody "want[s] to cause mass death". Arguing at the level of subjective intentions trivialises the complications of large-scale social change.
Re:On the Left by jwhitlark on Sunday June 05, 2016 @02:51PM (#11842440)
People always believe their form of extremism is justified. That's what makes it so dangerous. I think we put a little too much emphasis on people's intention, and not enough on the result of their actions.
Re:On the Left by eli_gottlieb on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:05PM (#11844404)
>People always believe their form of extremism is justified.

Of course, people always believe other people's moderate proposals are dangerous extremism.

For instance, the FBI considered Martin Luther King Jr a dangerous extreme leftist to be spied-upon for the sake of national security, and of course, part of the reason MLKJr was actually a socialist was precisely because mid-century America's idea of "moderate" and "normal" was that prosperity for the white working-class could and should be purchased with the tortuous exploitation of the black and immigrant working classes, and that anyone who would run a Poor People's Campaign for all colors together was a dangerous extremist who had to die.

Re:On the Left by jwhitlark on Monday June 06, 2016 @01:00AM (#11844757)
I was trying to point out that he was describing himself as extreme, and when people say they're willing to go to extremes, I both take them at their word and get nervous.
Re:On the Left by Grue3 on Sunday June 05, 2016 @10:09AM (#11841026)
Nobody thinks they're a bad guy. However we have tried communism several times and it had inevitably and independently led to unimaginable atrocities. At this point ignorance is not an excuse.
Re:On the Left by room271 on Sunday June 05, 2016 @12:11PM (#11841606)
He's not suggesting communism!
Re:On the Left by svensken on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:19PM (#11849502)
When you look back on the history of communism, you sure do see a lot of red flags.
Re:On the Left by samastur on Sunday June 05, 2016 @07:30AM (#11840457)
Because being left-wing does not even mean you are a communist and even if you were it would not mean you support the way they tried to implement it.

Left-wing without context and location doesn't say much useful.

Re:On the Left by jwhitlark on Sunday June 05, 2016 @03:07PM (#11842525)
Regarding your second point, "They didn't do it right" is no longer a viable argument for/defense of Communism. It's been tried too many times by too many people and failed too terribly. At the very minimum, it would have to be "this is so hard to do right that no one has managed it, despite lots of trying."
Re:On the Left by eli_gottlieb on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:07PM (#11844410)
State-centered command economies have indeed been tried, and have indeed shown a very mixed record. Of course, only some of those have been called Communist. The rest were called Capitalist, and are just as mixed.

The 20th century's distinction between "capitalist" and "communist", "free" and "not free", doesn't seem to have actually captured genuinely relevant dimensions of variation very well.

Re:On the Left by samastur on Thursday June 09, 2016 @03:26PM (#11871674)
I am not defending communism. I think it is doomed because it ignores human nature just as some other isms do. However that doesn't mean that those who disagree with me would necessarily do it in one of the ways it has been tried so far.

I also don't think words mean the same thing to all people. As someone who spent his youth in a socialist country I can assure you Bernie Sanders idea of socialism is very different to what "we" thought it was or what other socialist countries were trying.

And that's really more or less my point. Left-wing doesn't really say much by itself without more information. There is no belief that would be shared by everyone who either describes themselves as left-wing or is described as such. Same for right-wing.

Re:On the Left by metaphorm on Sunday June 05, 2016 @03:07PM (#11842523)
congratulations! you managed to get to Godwin's law with a top level comment. hole in one!