Re:On the Left
by eli_gottlieb on Sunday June 05, 2016 @11:01PM
(#11844383)
>* peak stuff ( we don't need to consume as much any more ) why would companies invest in new jobs and infrastructure when they are not going to recoup the cost through growing sales ?
We currently have a glut of consumer goods, but they're mostly consumer goods with low marginal desirability, and we actually have a shortage of physical capital, collective infrastructure, and equipment for personal empowerment.
To wit: it's better to have affordable, high-quality education and public transit, at the margins, than the N+1st craft brewery.
Re:On the Left
by sievebrain on Sunday June 05, 2016 @04:02PM
(#11842820)
I would say unfunded pensions and "peak stuff" are contradictions. We clearly need/want to consume more than is readily available due to investments not paying off sufficiently well.
We don't inhabit a true Capitalist society any more ( my term for the current system is Crapitalism )
Further it is unclear if our current machine can survive
* peak stuff ( we don't need to consume as much any more ) why would companies invest in new jobs and infrastructure when they are not going to recoup the cost through growing sales ?
* population still on the rise . Where do jobs come from for 10 billion when we've hit peak stuff
* robber barons control the laws, courts and media ( a constant over human existence)
* massive debt load ( unfunded pensions, national debts, private mortgage debts )
But I would ask Tim Bray what I ask everyone else who says radical measures are required. Namely, how is the transition made without mass cleansing and warfare in the interim.
Often ( Viet Cong, Khmer Rouge, Mao, Stalin ) the middle class and educated are unfairly lumped in with the elite and exterminated.
Is the current brokenness worth millions dead, and proportionally lots of HNers ?