Re:Common shell script mistakes (2008)
by cgriswald on Sunday June 05, 2016 @01:41AM
(#11839787)
> Well, even in itself, it is wrong.
I am not in disagreement with you about whether it is wrong, I am in disagreement with you about why it is wrong.
The counter argument was that Y is wrong and X is Y, therefore X is wrong. While this is a valid argument, it is not sound, because X is not Y.
> ... succinctness is quite orthogonal to readability ...
There is a relationship between succinctness and readability. The relationship is definitely not directly proportional as the pwd_mkdb's post could be read to imply, but to say there is no relationship between the two is flatly absurd.
I am not in disagreement with you about whether it is wrong, I am in disagreement with you about why it is wrong.
The counter argument was that Y is wrong and X is Y, therefore X is wrong. While this is a valid argument, it is not sound, because X is not Y.
> ... succinctness is quite orthogonal to readability ...
There is a relationship between succinctness and readability. The relationship is definitely not directly proportional as the pwd_mkdb's post could be read to imply, but to say there is no relationship between the two is flatly absurd.