If they didn't peer with anyone they'd be a closed network and it would be illegal to advertise that as "internet access".
They're legally required to live up to the claims of their product. If they say X Mbit/s then there needs to be at least a plausible case made that they can achieve those results. Anything significantly less is to invite a class-action lawsuit.
Can you clarify a bit? I'm not sure what you mean.
An ISP isn't, by law, required to peer with anyone.