News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What happens when private equity buys your competitor? by ryandrake on Friday June 03, 2016 @12:46PM (#11831430)
> Founders are special people who somehow glimpse a vision of the future that few others understand, and then go build it.

Ughh, more founder-worship. What's more believable is that lots and lots of people can see glimpses of the future all around them. Out of that larger set, the ones that are lucky enough to have access to the capital and connections needed to start up and run a company are the ones that end up as "founders".

Re:What happens when private equity buys your competitor? by mwfunk on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:36PM (#11833089)
Even worse is when someone's founder mythologization (if that's a word :) reaches the point where they always capitalize the word "founder" and talk about founders (sorry, Founders) as if they were some unique species distinct from all other humans for their vision and bravery.

I'm convinced this comes from a combination of extremely stressed-out people psyching themselves up, plus VCs wanting to psych up the fresh meat. If you're going to give someone a bunch of money on the off chance that they might turn it into more money, it helps if you can convince the people you're giving money to that they are courageous superhuman visionaries creating the future, rather than people who are about to ruin their lives for a few years in exchange for a small chance at a big payout.

Re:What happens when private equity buys your competitor? by avs733 on Saturday June 04, 2016 @01:03AM (#11834992)
>mythologization (if that's a word :)

The term I have heard used is mythicizing or mythization[1] but its not only a problem in the public sphere, it has a significant impact on entrepreneurial research and understanding/teaching entrepreneurship.

[1] Ogbor, J. O. (2000). Mythicizing and reification in entrepreneurial discourse: Ideology-critique of entrepreneurial studies. Journal of Management Studies, 37(5), 605–635. http://doi.org/10.1111/1467-6486.00196

Re:What happens when private equity buys your competitor? by foxylad on Friday June 03, 2016 @07:37PM (#11834026)
This. I suppose I am a successful founder, but it sure wasn't some mystical "vision of the future" - I have about ten of those a day, and I'm sure everyone else does too.

We succeeded due to blind luck - right place, right time. And a lot of hard work of course, but there are multitudes working just as hard who don't succeed because their thing isn't quite compelling enough, or a large competitor suddenly appears out of nowhere, or even the stock photo they used is also used by a popular gambling website and turns people off.

I guess the whole VC thing is predicated on the idea that you can pick winners, and therefore those winners (founders) must be something special. We're not - we're just dice that came up six.

Re:What happens when private equity buys your competitor? by ben_jones on Friday June 03, 2016 @09:50PM (#11834514)
This. Can't mention luck and coincidence enough. Most startups can trace their success to meeting person x at the right time in the right way. X be an investor, an engineer, a business developer, whatever.
Re:What happens when private equity buys your competitor? by ianbicking on Friday June 03, 2016 @02:32PM (#11832250)
It seems like it would be sufficient to say that not everyone has the ability to glimpse the future, envision a product given that, and initiate and direct the implementation of that product. Not everyone has that ability, but probably many do: however, in an established business with specific fiscal goals, how many people have the ability to do those things? Founders don't just bring some evidence of talent, they also have an authority and influence to make things happen that other people don't. Another way of thinking about it is that an established company typically does not have the ability to develop and empower that kind of person within the company. A founder precedes the company, and so is not constrained by the company in the same way.
Re:What happens when private equity buys your competitor? by ryandrake on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:00PM (#11832816)
My point is that "founder" is not some distinct species of human that uniquely and intrinsically possesses product sense, future-seeing vision, ability to execute, etc. etc. etc. There are many people out there with these abilities, and they could just as successfully found and grow companies. What sets apart founders is that they have these traits AND have the access to capital and connections that permit them to actually go out and do it.

For example, I would put forward as a basis of argument:

There are many people (thousands?) who, given $1 billion, could go off and build a space program. Elon Musk was actually able to do it though, not because he's a genius (he is), but because he ALSO is super-well-connected and actually could gain access to that $1 billion.

Re:What happens when private equity buys your competitor? by gumby on Friday June 03, 2016 @01:05PM (#11831568)
Well, that's on a VC blog so it's a sales pitch do get people to pitch them. All businesses will tell you "we love you".

Of course the entrepreneurs (founders or not) are not the customers, the LPs are.

Re:What happens when private equity buys your competitor? by blazespin on Friday June 03, 2016 @01:44PM (#11831875)
Just curious, it sounds like you think this statement is either not true or just a coincidence: " In consumer technology, especially, there are very few success stories that don’t involve at least one founder in an active role. "

My past experience is that it's actually pretty true. Some individual from the beginning of the company needs to be in an active role until a certain degree of maturity sets in.

Sometimes they need to bring that guy back after he leaves and things fall apart.

I've never done a statistical analysis though, so maybe I and the lightspeed guy are wrong.

Re:What happens when private equity buys your competitor? by ryandrake on Friday June 03, 2016 @01:55PM (#11831964)
I think for sure that company success requires engaged, future-seeing leaders with vision, taking an active role. My argument is that "founders" are not the sole possessors of such leadership qualities. The "founder" title has much more to do with one's access to capital and connections than one's intrinsic personal qualities or product judgment.
Re:What happens when private equity buys your competitor? by galistoca on Friday June 03, 2016 @05:54PM (#11833559)
So it sounds like you think you have the "glimpse of the future". Well, nothing is stopping you from doing it RIGHT NOW, instead of posting on HN about how you need money to do anything.

When you think you have a good idea but not working on it, it probably means either: 1. you don't think the idea is good enough to risk your stable life; 2. you are too lazy to do it; 3. you don't want to risk regardless of how great of an idea you think it is.

In every one of these cases, you're not cut out to be a founder--you just can't do the most important part--"then go build it". That's what makes "founders" special, they just do it instead of complaining how it can't be done.