News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by fab13n on Friday June 03, 2016 @06:56AM (#11829530)
I'm an upper-middle class, over-educated professional expert, and I'm strongly liberal for selfish reasons: mostly, I want to live in a climate of social peace, and would prefer to be surrounded by people who foster a mood of solidarity and benevolence, rather than a cut-throat and ever-worsening competitive mindset.

So sure, one way is to protect myself and those I love behind a gated community. But that's pretty much voluntarily throwing myself to jail, I'd rather make it less necessary for others to be aggressive against my kin. I believe it requires more (and smarter) redistribution.

Another reason why it's my selfish interest, as a professional expert, to continuously reshuffle wealth, is that my social value resides in what I know and in my ability to learn, not in my family's accumulated wealth. Stabilising accumulated wealth, especially across generations, would make it harder to use my skills in order to climb higher on the social ladder.

Is my education a factor in this view? Probably.

* It helps me grasping some sociological insights which ought to be obvious. For instance, while hearing political speeches about wealth (re)distribution, I stay aware that the property laws are a social construct that must be agreed upon and can be altered at will by society, not a natural (let alone a God-given) law.

* It exposed me to a lot of competition, in school then at work, and although I've been a winner on average, I aspire to more fulfilling activities than turning others into losers. I have no revenge to take on others people, I don't enjoy crushing them.

* Having gone from penniless undergrad to minimum-wage PhD student to well-paid junior then senior specialist, I've experienced a variety of wealth levels. As a result I'm convinced that once basic needs are addressed, monetary incentives don't work the way Adam Smith' sycophants pretend they do. Money's meaningful as a way to keep score, and to compare myself among my social peers; but taxes don't affect that much, as long as they don't reverse relative wealth between potential peers.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by ArkyBeagle on Friday June 03, 2016 @05:40PM (#11833471)
If they're wrong ( and oh so many are ) , "Adam Smith's sycophants" have a fundamental reading comprehension problem. He's nominally a tepid-right, Virginia school economist, but Russ Roberts frames "Wealth of Nations" as a drill down of "Theory of Moral Sentiments". Smith spends barrels of ink decrying rents.

Many, many people who espouse Smith just cherry-pick reinforcement from him. Now: having said that, I am no progressive. I'd actually be for redistribution if it could be shown to work; we can't even get insurance payments fo people from Hurricane Sandy right. There is just always a paucity of philsopher-kings. We're just not that smart. It takes decades for the permanent bureaucratic class to debug these things - look at the history of the relativelty simple ( and possibly brilliant ) ag. subsidy regime.

I don't think we have a good empirical handle on aggression. I've known too many wealthy people who I would not turn my back on. I've known too many saintly/salt-of-the-earth/shirt-off-their-back poor people. The proportions do not favor material comfort having much of a seat at the table.

The cultural more of "crushing people" kinda looks like a thing now, and it makes me modestly angry.

I view Smith as one element of the (very important) Scots Enlightenment, along with Hume, James Watt and all the others. Where those guys are/were right, they're still right. That's my bias, though.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by tim333 on Friday June 03, 2016 @07:56PM (#11834106)
In practice altering the distribution of wealth and income doesn't usually involve taking from A and giving to B. It usually is more taking from the rich and spending the money on free education and the like. You can also put taxes on large estates, give subsidised houses / loans to the less well off and so on.

There used to be quite a lot of that between WW2 and Thatcher getting in in the UK with tax rates as high as 98%. The period of this song https://youtu.be/pzU2owPegHE?t=23s

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by ArkyBeagle on Saturday June 04, 2016 @05:05PM (#11838036)
In general, if you subsidize something you get more of it and it costs more. Of course there may be some odd current in the river which makes this untrue - an example is bulk grain subsidies in the US, which prices risk of underproduction way down. IMO, this is like "if you need 4 GB RAM , get 8 just to be safe".

Indeed, in both housing and in education, we've subsidized it, there is more of it and it costs more.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by kilotaras on Monday June 06, 2016 @03:32PM (#11849606)
>in both housing and in education, we've subsidized it, there is more of it and it costs more.

What about all of Europe that has almost free education?

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by xbmcuser on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:08AM (#11835317)
Overall even the rich benefit from higher taxes if the middle class had more income today most of them would have been spending it on things the rich provide. Today by squeezing the middle class and lower middle class they might be making money but over long term with the middle class having lower disposable income they will be spending less so hurt the higher classes as well.
Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by jedmeyers on Friday June 03, 2016 @08:18PM (#11834208)
And also the period of this album https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FwfpcTYv7Ts&list=PL7sBCGkQNm...

'Exile' in the title is not a coincidence.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by Kurtz79 on Friday June 03, 2016 @07:58AM (#11829769)
"I'm an upper-middle class, over-educated professional expert, and I'm strongly liberal for selfish reasons: mostly, I want to live in a climate of social peace, and would prefer to be surrounded by people who foster a mood of solidarity and benevolence, rather than a cut-throat and ever-worsening competitive mindset."

That's mostly my rationale for being in favor of (moderate) wealth redistribution, which on surface would be against my interests, as someone by no means wealthy but with an above-median income.

What's the point of having money if you cannot walk safely among people ?

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by rubyfan on Friday June 03, 2016 @08:25AM (#11829877)
Is resource redistribution the only way to solve income inequality? I always believed we weren't playing a zero sum game. It's likely that when we are all working for a living and prospering then we all prosper a little more. I don't believe that means someone rich has to lose a little more so someone poor can win.
Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by antisthenes on Friday June 03, 2016 @10:44AM (#11830590)
> I always believed we weren't playing a zero sum game. It's likely that when we are all working for a living and prospering then we all prosper a little more. I don't believe that means someone rich has to lose a little more so someone poor can win.

If you studied economics, you'd very quickly realize that many areas that people compete for and responsible for inequality are zero-sum (at least in the short-run and medium-run). It is more tricky for wealth, since once person owning something more esoteric, like a portfolio does not necessarily preclude anyone else from doing so.

The most notable example, of course, is real estate, especially in the areas where zoning laws prohibit from building upwards. You might also know it as a NIMBY suburban sprawl, which is one of the biggest factors in creating inequality and misery in the US.

Another example that I haven't explored fully is political influence. The attention and decision-making of policymakers is definitely zero-sum by virtue of there being a fixed amount of them.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by rubyfan on Saturday June 04, 2016 @07:51AM (#11835991)
I don't believe that the laborer and the software developer are competing for the same resources in most cases. They are not playing a zero sum game. Their resource accumulations are based on market conditions, the market allocates toward value of utility in a mostly efficient manner.

Why would we move from a set of natural laws that govern allocation to a central authority based one? Ie, why should government take from the software developer some of his resource so that the laborer has more than what the market would allocate?

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by Kurtz79 on Friday June 03, 2016 @09:57AM (#11830312)
"It's likely that when we are all working for a living and prospering then we all prosper a little more."

Do you seriously think this is an achievable goal ?

There will be always people that can't or won't work hard for a living. It might be due to their upbringing, education, DNA, personal choices, health conditions, personality. It doesn't mean that these people should be left to their own devices, for the "selfish" reasons mentioned by the OP, if not for more "noble" ones.

Resource redistribution does not aim to "solve" income inequality, but to lessen its side effects. It might be not the only way, it is definitely not perfect and you might say it is not fair, but at least it is a realistic way to tackle a difficult problem.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by rskar on Friday June 03, 2016 @10:33AM (#11830522)
"It's likely that when we are all working for a living and prospering then we all prosper a little more." Well, of course, we all prosper when we all are prospering. :)

While life isn't exactly a zero-sum game, for certain moments it works that way. In any case, for now (nearly) all of us are Earth-bounded, so the limits of what our planet and our Sun can provide to us (over time) is what truly matters. There's only so much of Earth to go around, and only so much radiation to be received from the Sun. (And I am of course overlooking the occasional changes from meteors and comets and other whatnot from the heavens.)

This thing about income (and wealth) inequality is about more than mere discontents. There are plenty who fear that our global economic system (leaning heavily on capitalism with sprinkles of socialism) will soon arrive at a point of being unsustainable - a point that arrives prior to actual resource depletion.

The heart of it is in the ways that people can be so entitled to things, such as water, food, clothing, shelter, education, offspring, healthcare, etc. The worries are about the consequences of greater portions of the population being at or below subsistence levels. This is especially alarming when the statistics show it growing more significant within "First-World" nations.

The three big factors seem to be (to me, anyway): (1) Strong property rights which enables more rentiers and natural monopolies; (2) Rentiers/Monopolizers out-competing most or all others for political and economic influences and favors; (3) human labor becoming less needed over time due to the growing rise of adaptable and reliable automation.

The automation of item 3 would make a "Galt's Gulch" more tenable, but it would probably be realized as an artificial island nation. Well, one can dream of one, anyway (see http://theweek.com/articles/482427/libertarian-island-billio...).

One can easily google on "wealth inequality" and get some sober/reasonable/academic reads on this. A good primer is at https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/05/21/the-t.... Also, look up NBER Working Paper No. 20625.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by dragonwriter on Friday June 03, 2016 @07:45PM (#11834058)
> Is resource redistribution the only way to solve income inequality?

Yes.

> I always believed we weren't playing a zero sum game.

That's true, so a redistribution can result in a net gain (or loss) of aggregate experienced utility. But you can't change the outcomes resulting from the current system of allocating resources without changing the allocation.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by metaphorm on Friday June 03, 2016 @08:26PM (#11834233)
It doesn't particularly matter if the game is zero-sum or not because of the way money interacts with influence/power. Essentially it is a bidding war, so those with the most money will always command the most influence by way of being able to bid the most. It doesn't matter that others are still gaining in their monetary compensation. They are still suffering through a widening deficit in power and agency.
Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by current_call on Saturday June 04, 2016 @03:29AM (#11835371)
Is resource redistribution the only way to solve income inequality?

You're asking the wrong question. Why is income inequality a problem?

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by ArkyBeagle on Friday June 03, 2016 @05:42PM (#11833485)
The better argument is marginal value of a dollar. The argument against is that effective investment creates an at least pseudo public good.

It's a nuanced mess and ideology destroys any hope of it being well done.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by jamesblonde on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:18PM (#11832944)
Here in Sweden the left wing fight to prevent universal social entitlements, but right wingers want them means tested. That's coherent with tho line of reasoning
Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by dragonwriter on Friday June 03, 2016 @05:47PM (#11833514)
> monetary incentives don't work the way Adam Smith' sycophants pretend they do

Well, they certainly work the Adam Smith said they do, to wit: "The interest of the dealers, however, in any particular branch of trade or manufactures, is always in some respects different from, and even opposite to, that of the public. To widen the market and to narrow the competition, is always the interest of the dealers."

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by panglott on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:14PM (#11832913)
People who are willing to endure being a grad student in order to become a professor are probably relatively less motivated by monetary incentives.
Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by ArkyBeagle on Friday June 03, 2016 @05:43PM (#11833493)
Some people are grad students with an eye towards finance.
Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by eli_gottlieb on Friday June 03, 2016 @03:33PM (#11832635)
You actually sound more like a social-democrat than a liberal. Liberals do not refer to property as a mere social construct.
Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by abritinthebay on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:16PM (#11832930)
To be fair though, and this is a common mistake, there is a world of difference between "Someone who holds general liberal positions" and "Someone who specifically subscribes to the policies of Classical Liberalism."

What you are referring to is Classical Liberalism which is a very specific thing.

What most people mean by "Liberal" is ideas of liberty and equality. Which is the generic form of Liberalism. (There are many sub-categories, including Classical, Conservative, Social, and Economic Liberalism)

Under those terms property would be a social construct (and contract).

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by harrumph on Friday June 03, 2016 @03:43PM (#11832703)
" Liberals do not refer to property as a mere social construct."

Excellent point. Liberals are de facto capitalists.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by eli_gottlieb on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:10PM (#11832879)
Liberals are capitalists with a heart. Social democrats are capitalists with a heart and a brain.

And personally, I think social democracy worked pretty ok except for the fact that it required a pretty strict anti-socialism, which meant that when the '70s arrived and the elite decided to "restore growth" by clawing back every concession to the working class and the human heart that they'd ever made under social democracy, nobody could stop them.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by ArkyBeagle on Friday June 03, 2016 @06:06PM (#11833623)
I cannot imagine a single meaningful thing "the elites" could do to have a concession to the human heart. They best they can do is things like taking the boot of Jim Crow off the neck of people. That's not that far from the arsonist-fireman syndrome.

Most of the concessions to the working class are still with us. Everything except jobs. And for a while, "restoring growth" worked. my hobby horse for why it stopped is low interest rates and low inflation.

Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by coupdetaco on Friday June 03, 2016 @07:42PM (#11834044)
Natural laws are the same as God given laws
Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by fab13n on Monday June 06, 2016 @09:29AM (#11846583)
Only if God exists, which is highly debatable and highly debated.
Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by lujim on Friday June 03, 2016 @04:11PM (#11832890)
You're also devastatingly modest ;)
Re:Why Are the Highly Educated So Liberal? by fab13n on Monday June 06, 2016 @09:28AM (#11846575)
Actually, I believe the description I gave of myself to match that of most of the left-leaning, >30yo HN commenters:-)