News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Test your “free will” at the Aaronson Oracle by jonathanyc on Thursday June 02, 2016 @03:25PM (#11825317)
Whether or not determinism and free will are compatible is a very intricate debate that your throwaway remark doesn't do justice to. Look up Compatibilism.
Re:Test your “free will” at the Aaronson Oracle by etjossem on Thursday June 02, 2016 @03:29PM (#11825346)
Also, Determinism (philosophy) != deterministic (computing)

The former is the metaphysical idea that all events are causally linked, a belief which we can never confirm or refute. The latter describes something's observable degree of predictability.

They're not related concepts at all. This demo has nothing to do with free will, Determinism, or Compatibilism - but it's an interesting study in predictability.

Re:Test your “free will” at the Aaronson Oracle by drdeca on Thursday June 02, 2016 @04:50PM (#11825936)
Is the distinction roughly "causally determined" vs "logically determined" ?

If we are talking about an abstract computing device, and whether it is deterministic, we mean whether its next state is always uniquely logically determined by the current state, correct?

Hmm, if an abstract machine behaves in a way that is uniquely logically determined, but which is not computable, do we consider such machines to be deterministic? I would think so, but I am not sure. We would be unable to predict it, does that make it not deterministic(computing) ?

Re:Test your “free will” at the Aaronson Oracle by SilasX on Thursday June 02, 2016 @07:32PM (#11827089)
Again, I was only speaking to the issue of whether it's misleading/clickbait to the average person, not whether they're really equal.