News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by di4na on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:30AM (#11823263)
Let's look at it the other way. Launching a movie cost a ton of money. So to keep a diverse culture ( we all agreee diversity is great isn't it?) and diverse way to think, you need to help less mainstream way to think.

You spend years elaborating complex way to let mainstream exists and makes money, without disturbing it too much, but still keep a working amount of culture disruptor and new ideas growing. And you even create way for the mainstream to do that, enabling cross pollination.

Then suddenly, a group that know nothing about your rules and believe that "all rules are bad anyway" come and control the main way to consume mainstream culture, rendering all your organisation void, cutting the money and support for the smallest groups.

Woops, you have to rebuild everything. Except that this time around, you have no grasp on that "mainstream" to get cooperation and build a working ecosystem.

The "market" is well and all. But an ecosystem need rulers and law enforcement. Too much rules is not good and i may agree that France and Europe was a bit too much (is a bit too much) coercive right now. But there is probably a middle ground that can be found.

Well now, i still believe lawmakers and rulers are decade behind the need of today technology. But it is not just "regulating consumption". It is also about future and keeping an healthy pool of new and fresh ideas.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by sievebrain on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:41AM (#11823370)
So to keep a diverse culture ( we all agreee diversity is great isn't it?)

No, we don't all agree. Not when the "diversity" is someone looking at the market and saying "there are too many good movies. we need some shit ones". Nobody needs to diversify away from quality, which is essentially what the French laws do.

Don't mistake the bizarre fetishes of a small number of French elite with some kind of natural law or elegant philosophy. The French government have to protect their cultural industry because it produces bad stuff that even the French don't want to watch. There is no justification for this: every attempted justification boils down to sophistry.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by hodwik on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:49AM (#11823467)
There are examples of more difficult media which don't get mass-media popular, not because of their quality, but because of their difficulty. These types of works make up part of the 'secret handshake' of the upper class -- it is how they identify each other.

France has the noble, but mistaken, idea that they can force lower and middle class people to take in high culture, and in so doing, will be able to make their country more egalitarian.

Sorry guys, cultural class isn't something you can just legislate away.

The upper classes (culturally, not economically) have spent generations training themselves to be very critical connoisseurs -- you're not going to undo that with some government-funded arthouse flicks and a Netflix tax.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by verroq on Thursday June 02, 2016 @12:12PM (#11823693)
>Not when the "diversity" is someone looking at the market and saying "there are too many good movies

I take it you are against affirmative action?

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by wfo on Thursday June 02, 2016 @01:41PM (#11824461)
And so we are to take your definition of "good" and "shit" as gospel -- obviously, we want more movies that you think are good and less movies that you think are shit. Would you like to take the position of cultural czar and pre-review every piece of art to decide if it's worth publishing?

Or perhaps you'd like us to just assume the market is the best judge of what is good art? That was a joke -- the notion is laughable, the market is a clumsy and incompetent tool in almost all human affairs, especially where art is involved.

Every justification boils down to referring to something that is difficult to understand (culture, art, subjectivity, the point of view of another person) which you have chosen to label as sophistry.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by sievebrain on Thursday June 02, 2016 @05:09PM (#11826091)
Yes, your second interpretation is the right one.

Oh, I'm sorry, you think what people choose to spend their money on is a poor way to judge what's good entertainment?

I suppose you're right - we should let French bureaucrats decide instead. Their tastes are far more exquisite than anyone elses, after all. It goes with the job.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by JoshTriplett on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:38AM (#11823336)
> But there is probably a middle ground that can be found.

There's a common failure mode (of both governments and other decision makers) of assuming that given two positions, the truth must lie somewhere in the middle. Sometimes one position is just wrong, and another is just right; the persistent presumption towards compromise allows wrong positions to chip away at the right one.

If you want to change laws, for instance, you need to provide evidence that the new position is actually better, not just that it's a compromise between what you proposed (and also didn't provide evidence for) and the status quo. Otherwise, the status quo should remain.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by strictnein on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:35AM (#11823313)
> "rendering all your organisation void, cutting the money and support for the smallest groups."

How does Netflix not offering enough French TV shows do that? Did the government just stop giving them money once Netflix showed up?

Also, encouraging Netflix to take on more local content is one thing. I'm sure they'd love to. Forcing them to fund the creation of local content is another thing completely. These governments are looking to require that a foreign company fund domestic businesses to be able to access their markets. Seems like something that would run afoul of the WTO, or similar body.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by kuschku on Thursday June 02, 2016 @12:41PM (#11823945)
> These governments are looking to require that a foreign company fund domestic businesses to be able to access their markets

So, like the All-American clause for almost all US govt. contracts?

Or the US punishment for VW, requiring them to produce specific cars in the US?

> Did the government just stop giving them money once Netflix showed up?

Where is the government supposed to get the money from, once they can’t make money with TV anymore?

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by strictnein on Thursday June 02, 2016 @12:52PM (#11824043)
Netflix isn't filling government contracts

Nor has Netflix lied to governments for years about the efficiency of their products and purposefully built devices to defeat government tests. VW is either facing massive multi billion dollar fines or has to reach other agreements.

VW has had access to the US for decades. Them building electric cars in the US has nothing to do with access to the US market.

Netflix will, in fact, be paying to license domestic content. And the more their customers watch domestic content, the more they will pay the content providers. The government itself will be cut out of the loop and that's really the problem here.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by kuschku on Friday June 03, 2016 @06:08AM (#11829330)
> VW has had access to the US for decades. Them building electric cars in the US has nothing to do with access to the US market.

That’s literally wrong.

The US government continually blocked VW from the US market, including the EPA sometimes taking 3 years for a single emission test.

As soon as a VW plant in the south of the US was built, somehow all that stopped.

> The government itself will be cut out of the loop and that's really the problem here.

Yes, and that’s the entire issue.

We’re getting a world where companies (which are basically dictatorships of the rich) are getting more power over governments. That doesn’t help anyone but the already rich.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by wildmusings on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:47AM (#11823447)
Shouldn't it be up to individual French people to decide what they watch on TV or the internet? Why should the coercive authority of the state have any say?
Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by bleuarff on Thursday June 02, 2016 @12:00PM (#11823581)
Probably because without these regulations, there would be no visibility for niche productions, no way for them to reach the few people who want to watch them. That may run contradictory to capitalist beliefs, but the system intends to allow existence of films/music/cultural products which (regardless of quality) have too few customers to survive in a non-regulated market.

If you wish to keep having diversity in your cultural industry, that's not a bad thing.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by yummyfajitas on Thursday June 02, 2016 @01:19PM (#11824283)
Unfortunately, due to the way broadcast television works, it's just not possible to cater to minority tastes. There's just no way to have the people who enjoy niche productions to pay the creators of those productions directly.

If only there were some sort of global system for distributing niche productions to those subscribers who want to see them. Perhaps some sort of system using minicomputers to transmit the information - we could call it "Minitel".

But seriously, are you really trying to claim that the internet is making it harder for niche producers and consumers to connect?

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by wfo on Thursday June 02, 2016 @01:47PM (#11824514)
Broadcast television can and has been catering to minority tastes for many, many years as we all know. It just can't bankroll itself by doing this, so it requires public funds or regulations to prop it up.

But sometimes making room for minority viewpoints/culture/attitudes is worth interrupting the all-consuming capitalist neoliberal worldview for a moment, if just long enough to allow someone to point out its many flaws.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by yummyfajitas on Thursday June 02, 2016 @01:58PM (#11824618)
Since you seem to have missed the sarcasm, I'll make it explicit.

There's this thing called the internet. It allows minority producers and minority consumers to connect with each other. For example, if you wish to read fiction about the Death Star's project manager, or My Little Pony characters living in the world of Fallout, or a rationalist-themed fanfic rewrite of Harry Potter, you can do so.

There is even erotic fanfic to the aforementioned Harry Potter fanfic.

It's never been easier for producers and consumers to find each other than today. If the stuff the French are trying to protect can't survive in the age of the internet, it's because no one likes it.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by wfo on Thursday June 02, 2016 @03:25PM (#11825319)
Yes, it lets hobbyists and amateurs connect with each other.

It doesn't help a well-respected cultural tradition of art continue and give it the tools it needs to continue to exist.

And plenty of people like it. The whole point of art is that often, if it's worth anything, the majority of people don't like it. Comparing art to erotic fanfics really quite makes my point for me -- the character of your argument is laid bare, you aren't willing or capable of making the distinction, it's all mindless entertainment and nothing more. The fight the French are fighting against is the lowest common denominator which replaces art -- valueless trash which is entertaining and nothing more. It is seductive and destructive and valuable monetarily but valueless otherwise.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by yummyfajitas on Thursday June 02, 2016 @03:42PM (#11825460)
The internet has made it easier than ever for content that only a tiny majority of people like to survive. If 99% of the population hates it and 1% loves it, you've got a viable business.

Discussing the "lowest common denominator" is an outdated argument from the broadcast television era. "Lowest common denominator" doesn't exist anymore due to entertainment becoming fragmented. When it premiered, Seinfeld's ratings were 8.0, making it #14 on TV. Today, the #1 show (Big Bang Theory) has ratings of 8.8.

http://www.thewrap.com/seinfeld-no-14-in-its-debut-season-wo...

http://www.nielsen.com/us/en/top10s.html

Lets face it - the problem with the stuff that you are defending is that it's enjoyed by fewer people than erotic meta-fanfic.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by wfo on Thursday June 09, 2016 @12:32AM (#11867566)
Actually yes we agree essentially -- it's not because it's enjoyed by fewer people, it's the ratio of cost to produce per person who will enjoy it.

The market isn't an effective vehicle for supporting art of any real value, it always has been.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by wolfgke on Thursday June 02, 2016 @02:05PM (#11824674)
> For example, if you wish to read fiction about the Death Star's project manager, or My Little Pony characters living in the world of Fallout, or a rationalist-themed fanfic rewrite of Harry Potter, you can do so. There is even erotic fanfic to the aforementioned Harry Potter fanfic.

Which all is only tolerated but not allowed by copyright laws.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by wildmusings on Thursday June 02, 2016 @02:25PM (#11824868)
His point was that the internet allows for much more diversity, rather than less. The example he chose is a little unfortunate. Copyright issues surrounding fan fiction are not relevant to the matter at hand.

I'd argue that the goal with the French cultural protectionist laws is not to allow diversity, but to choose winners and losers by constraining choice.

Re:Why the World Is Drawing Battle Lines Against American Te... by wildmusings on Thursday June 02, 2016 @10:07PM (#11827814)
>But sometimes making room for minority viewpoints/culture/attitudes is worth interrupting the all-consuming capitalist neoliberal worldview for a moment, if just long enough to allow someone to point out its many flaws.

So affirmative action for ideas? If you can't win, maybe you can win by forcing people to listen to you?