News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by wslh on Thursday June 02, 2016 @10:37AM (#11822758)
(Note to Jack Dorsey fans: if you want to downvote downvote with arguments)

Obviously Jack Dorsey is not very capable and is bad at business execution. There is/was a simple way to increase Twitter revenue and profits: giving small and medium companies a way to pay for entry level access to their API in the same way Google AdWords, etc work. I think there is a lot of money there but they only know about wholeselling to companies/agencies with big budgets.

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by FilterSweep on Thursday June 02, 2016 @10:54AM (#11822923)
Parent does have some validity related to their API...and how they've scorned developers - but the API, and all of Developers in the "Twitter Sphere", are such a small portion of what Twitter "does" it would be out of scope for their investors to bank on TwitterAPI to reach projections.

I don't think Dorsey is as bad as you claim, but this example does reflect an (IMO) systemic problem of treating the CEO of large companies (~N > 50) as a superhero when institutional and foundational changes would really be the hero of the story.

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by wslh on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:04AM (#11823019)
> but the API, and all of Developers in the "Twitter Sphere", are such a small portion of what Twitter "does" it would be out of scope for their investors to bank on TwitterAPI to reach projections.

I don't think so. The development ecosystem is (or was) a way to reinforce the platform, it is a kind of partnership where you stimulate Twitter use because you can build or take value on top of it. Many startups or businesses in general look elsewhere for the information that is available on Twitter.

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by FilterSweep on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:44AM (#11823413)
We're saying the same thing here, in premise. There is some value to be gained from a development ecosystem, undeniably.

The difference between what I'm saying is that the sheer magnitude of unmonetized Twitter Web users makes whatever small fish monetization increasing Twitter use with their integration look like chump change.

Now, there are several big players such as Periscope, Vine, Meerkat, that could have benefitted Twitter greatly from offering a development ecosystem. But there are two reasons why they wouldn't:

1) Twitter, like Facebook, is big enough - or, more accurately, are expected to be big enough - to be in the "acquirer" phase where they derive more value competing against and acquiring than playing with these popular new services. However, we've seen much of the industry being overvalued and some of us believe a small company can do more, faster, on a technical level than a big company due to bureaucracy, so expectations aren't always matching up to reality.

Vine and Periscope were eventually acquired by Twitter. And Meerkat was forced to pivot.

2) There are cost-benefit analyses that neither you, nor I, are privy to which found developing and maintaining an API by relatively highly-paid employees not worth the benefits seen by its integration by other companies.

> Many startups or businesses in general look elsewhere for the information that is available on Twitter.

Are you sure of this? Businesses and other startups alike still use Twitter for engagement, and there is great information to be pulled from Twitter, assuming they have the ability to act on the metrics available.

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by wslh on Thursday June 02, 2016 @01:22PM (#11824309)
> Are you sure of this?

Yes. For example, you can't analyze your social graph with their current API limitations. Just moving one degree in the graph hit the limit.

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by prawn on Thursday June 02, 2016 @10:54AM (#11822916)
You might be copping downvotes because people think your arguments that he's "not very capable" and "is bad at business execution" don't hold up?
Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by talmand on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:00AM (#11822980)
As a third party I would be interested in hearing why others feel the arguments don't hold up. Just simply clicking the downvote button doesn't make for an interesting discussion.
Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by askldfhjkasfhd on Thursday June 02, 2016 @03:57PM (#11825561)
The overwhelming opinion* seems to be that he's brilliant at what he does. The post said it's obvious he's bad at business. If it's really that obvious, how did everyone else get things so wrong?

A more transparent post would have said something like "Based on my world view, assumptions, and preconceptions, he's bad at business. The common narrative of Dorsey is XYZ. Here's why that's wrong."

Saying "it's obvious" when you're expressing an uncommon opinion doesn't set a good tone for a discussion. Makes it seem like "I'm smart they're dumb I don't need to explain my statement that runs counter to conventional wisdom".

* Not saying it's right, just that this is what the Twitter board / media / insiders / VCs /etc. seem to think.

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by talmand on Thursday June 02, 2016 @05:40PM (#11826293)
That's not actually a response to my statement, even though it may be true. You're just providing an excuse to downvote without bothering to engage in discussion as to why to downvote. I want to hear the reasons for the downvote.

Just thinking I can downvote and not respond because of the "obvious" problems of the statement is just as bad as your example of saying "it's obvious" about an uncommon opinion is not good for discussion. You're just telling me "it's obvious" why the other guy's "it's obvious" is wrong.

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by askldfhjkasfhd on Thursday June 02, 2016 @06:43PM (#11826731)
Back up the bus - I didn't downvote. I start a new HN account well before I ever get that invested.

There really wasn't an argument put forth beyond "he's bad at business, can't you see it's obvious". His tone and lack of content other than an unsubstantiated opinion are why there was no interesting discussion.

I never said "it's obvious" in any way shape or form, but I do believe this is my stop. Have a nice day.

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by wslh on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:18PM (#11828076)
> His tone and lack of content other than an unsubstantiated opinion are why there was no interesting discussion.

It was not unsubstantiated. If I define a good business as a business with profits, this definition has a lot of substance. Jack Dorsey obviously achieved a lot of personal success and money from Twitter, I am not blind about his amazing achievements. Amazing because they are statistically difficult to obtain at this scale. BUT, being a public company is a different stage of the game. As an startup you can be amazing while the finances are hidden but when you are public you need to build a sustainable business and this is not happening.

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by prawn on Friday June 03, 2016 @03:18AM (#11828849)
He also has his involvement in Square, Inc.
Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by wslh on Thursday June 02, 2016 @10:58AM (#11822963)
Business capabilities are judged by $$$ even when chance plays a big role. There is no signal of turn around.
Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by reitanqild on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:33AM (#11823283)
Well well. Who knows where twitter would have been now if it wasn't for Jack Dorsey.

With a product so boring (IMO) that the only two interesting things about it (again IMO) are the massive hype and the resulting massive scale, just keeping the hype machine running is quite a feat IMO ;-)

(Yeah, when I first saw it I saw massive potential: kind of a giant global event/message bus with a mix of more or less personal text messages, machine2machine communications etc etc. I thought the first thing they would do would be adding channels so you could separate various topics, paid subscriptions for internal company discussions etc etc. Instead they doubled down on efficient distribution of spam and drivel :-/)

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by wslh on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:40AM (#11823359)
> Well well. Who knows where twitter would have been now if it wasn't for Jack Dorsey.

100% agree but now the company is in another stage, it is a public company and it is scrutinized with different standards.

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by rsync on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:05AM (#11823031)
"(Note to Jack Dorsey fans: if you want to downvote downvote with arguments)"

Don't discuss your own votes.

Don't interrupt the actual discussion to meta-discuss the scoring system.

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by reitanqild on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:22AM (#11823179)
> Don't discuss your own votes.

I don't think that is what OP meant, rather than please add a comment explaining why it is wrong (instead of downvoting and moving on.)

Re:Twitter Is Betting Everything on Jack Dorsey by wslh on Thursday June 02, 2016 @11:15AM (#11823115)
I used parentheses that can be read in less than 1 second. Let me know if you are a HN moderator.