Re:The Internet is nominated for this year's Nobel Peace Prize.
by njl on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @04:10PM
(#1181993)
This feels more like the Time Magazine "Man of the Year" than it does a serious attempt to highlight those who have provided the "greatest benefit on mankind".
The Nobel Peace Prize can serve a very real purpose; it can highlight someone working peacefully to overthrow an authoritarian regime. It can give those advocating for an improvement of the human condition a voice, international standing, a modicum of protection from government violence, and resources.
Using the Peace Prize (and the Economics Prize, for that matter) as a way to deliver short-sited political digs or kudos to one group or another is farcical. It should go to people who are on the ground, working right now, to make the world a better place.
Re:The Internet is nominated for this year's Nobel Peace Prize.
by megamark16 on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @02:46PM
(#1181777)
Now this is just getting ridiculous. There are people and organizations out there making the world better, saving lives, saving the world. Please stop with the theatrics.
Re:The Internet is nominated for this year's Nobel Peace Prize.
by ascuttlefish on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @02:21PM
(#1181703)
"It is unclear who would accept the prize if the internet were to win."
No doubt. The internet is a passive tool; it's the people and organizations using it for good who should be winning prizes. The Nobel Peace Prize should be less nebulous, and for concrete achievement. (Edited for grammar.)
Re:The Internet is nominated for this year's Nobel Peace Prize.
by sp332 on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @03:44PM
(#1181919)
That's the World-Wide Web, not the Internet. The Internet enables email, IM & IRC, online gaming, SSH, online backups, voice & video conferencing, and the World-Wide Web.
Re:The Internet is nominated for this year's Nobel Peace Prize.
by jriddycuz on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @04:43PM
(#1182072)
Why not? The irony of giving a peace prize to a military organization would clearly escape the grasp of this increasingly irrelevant group of nominators.
Re:The Internet is nominated for this year's Nobel Peace Prize.
by anamax on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @05:40PM
(#1182209)
> Why not? The irony of giving a peace prize to a military organization would clearly escape the grasp of this increasingly irrelevant group of nominators.
Western Europe was liberated by military organizations. The resulting several decades of peace had something to do with military organizations as well.
Short of Norman Borlaug, military organizations have produced more peace than anyone else.
Re:The Internet is nominated for this year's Nobel Peace Prize.
by jriddycuz on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @06:30PM
(#1182325)
Good point, and with a few qualifications I agree with you. But the actual intent of the prize, as expressed by Alfred Nobel himself, mentions the reduction of standing armies as a qualification for receiving the award.
Re:The Internet is nominated for this year's Nobel Peace Prize.
by fnid2 on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @03:54PM
(#1181947)
Cut the shenanigans and just nominate TBL! He actually deserves it. He hasn't sought out peace, as another commented suggested the prize should focus on, but indirectly, he's caused a lot of peace through communication.
Kissinger, Arafat, a newly-inaugurated president who justified the wars he was continuing in his acceptance speech, and now a communications medium.
Retire the Peace Prize. They clearly have no idea what to do with it.
The Nobel Peace Prize can serve a very real purpose; it can highlight someone working peacefully to overthrow an authoritarian regime. It can give those advocating for an improvement of the human condition a voice, international standing, a modicum of protection from government violence, and resources.
Using the Peace Prize (and the Economics Prize, for that matter) as a way to deliver short-sited political digs or kudos to one group or another is farcical. It should go to people who are on the ground, working right now, to make the world a better place.
No doubt. The internet is a passive tool; it's the people and organizations using it for good who should be winning prizes. The Nobel Peace Prize should be less nebulous, and for concrete achievement. (Edited for grammar.)
Western Europe was liberated by military organizations. The resulting several decades of peace had something to do with military organizations as well.
Short of Norman Borlaug, military organizations have produced more peace than anyone else.
I hadn't noticed that the world is different due to the internet.
But, I want my 0.0013 of an SEK.