Intel's big advantage has been their ability to reliably and continually improve their manufacturing process, and for this to reliably and continually deliver performance improvements (the tick/tock strategy).
There have been a number of times when other companies beat Intel to a new technology (introducing, say, the 64 Bit chip several months ahead), but when the market took off and the cycle began, only Intel was able to deliver in sufficient quantity.
This is entirely untrue. AMD delivered a better consumer-focused 64bit architecture, and for an entire generation the Athlon outperformed the Pentium4. Yes, Intel sold plenty, but AMD did too.
That was the last time Intel made a misstep in their x64 product line.
Nowdays, desktop chips are facing some challenges. TSMC, Samsung and other are able to deliver plenty of ARM chips to market for the phone and tablet chips. Nvidia is increasingly eating the compute market.
This wasn't the case during the x64 transition, which was the example you used. To quote Wikipedia:
In commercial terms, the Athlon "Classic" was an enormous success not just because of its own merits, but also because Intel endured a series of major production, design, and quality control issues at this time. In particular, Intel's transition to the 180 nm production process, starting in late 1999 and running through to mid-2000, suffered delays. There was a shortage of Pentium III parts.[citation needed] In contrast, AMD enjoyed a remarkably smooth process transition and had ample supplies available, causing Athlon sales to become quite strong[1]
However, that was during the early 2000s. Since 2007, Intel has continually improved their processes and architectures on a reliable timeline[2], and haven't had any significant problems delivering those continual improvements.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Athlon#Athlon_.22Classic.22
I assume you meant to say "Since 2007, AMD has continually improved..."
So I stand corrected in that I didn't realize AMD had closed the gap.
However, my point was about the relative manufacturing ability of Intel and its competitors. Am I to understand your claim that AMD's manufacturing is (approximately) as good as Intel's at the moment?
I don't have any new information, but its a very, very hard problem. And a brief google search seems to indicate that AMD has faced more recent challenges: http://www.wired.com/2012/03/amd-global-foundries/
No, Intel is the one with the reliable continual improvement process. That is their advantage, not ability to manufacture large volumes.
The middle of the road is shrinking fast.
Therefore, Intel's competitive advantage of running their own fabs could keep them ahead in the server space as well.
Intel derives much of its competitive advantage from its ability to manufacture.
This means that a lot of Intel's advantage will only express itself when the market grows really large. There have been a number of times when other companies beat Intel to a new technology (introducing, say, the 64 Bit chip several months ahead), but when the market took off and the cycle began, only Intel was able to deliver in sufficient quantity.
I don't know what the total market for a particular chip is likely to be, or how fast it will get there.