News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fandom Is Broken by tzs on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:13PM (#11809811)
That's a "blind men and an elephant" characterization. GamerGate and anti-GG are much more complicated than that. Here's a copy/paste of a comment of mine from a year or so ago after I spent way too much time trying to unravel this. I found at least 4 or 5 distinct groups with quite different goals involved:

1. People who are in fact concerned about the sorry ethical state of game journalism.

2. Trolls and jerks who have jumped in to cause trouble, mostly by attacking women in groups #3 and #4.

3. The game journalists whose ethics are being called into question.

4. Assorted "social justice" activists. They showed up because the original spark that set all this off was a lying, vindictive open letter from an ex-boyfriend of a female developer, accusing her and some journalists of unethical practices, and that caused the developer to receive some very inappropriate comments. The letter was fairly quickly discredited, but the incident did get many fired up to do something about long standing unethical game journalists, which had long been something people were annoyed about but never got organized enough to do anything about, which is what led to the formation of group #1.

5. Group #1 includes many female gamers. Many of them have been receiving death threats and rape threats. It's not clear if these are coming from people in group #4, or if there is a distinct group of trolls and jerks similar to #2 but who have decided to attack #1 instead of #3 and #4.

• group #1 is concentrating on fighting #3, and trying to keep #2 out.

• group #2 is attacking #3 and #4, and trying to make sure #1 gets blamed.

• group #3 is trying hard to make sure people don't consider the points of #1, by making sure to cover all the activities of #2, which they attribute to #1, and ignoring group #5's activities.

• group #4 is fighting group #2's actions, which they often attribute to group #1.

• group #5 is fighting the women in group #1.

There may be other groups. The women in group #1 maybe should be considered a separate group, because in addition to fighting #3, many of them are also fighting #4.

Re:Fandom Is Broken by tptacek on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:37PM (#11810826)
The problem with this analysis is "GamerGate" is, and was within days of being coined, overwhelmingly defined by group (2). It does not help at all that one of the first sparks igniting the "ethics in journalism" conflagration was a tell-all open letter from the jilted ex-lover of a female game developer; in a universe of slime and corruption in every form of trade journalism, GamerGate chose this one to get started over.

Are there ethical issues in the trade press? Of course there are. But good-faith advocates of clean trade journalism by and large shun the label "GamerGate", because it's so pungently associated with bad-faith advocacy that targets women.

Therefore, identifying multiple distinct factions embroiled in "the GamerGate controversy", even if they include people with a legitimate interest in "ethics in journalism", just isn't dispositive. The argument that GamerGate is about misogyny easily survives that rebuttal.

Re:Fandom Is Broken by belorn on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @10:26AM (#11814561)
Maybe good-faith advocates avoided the discussion rather than receiving death threats like TotalBiscuit. Clearly, neither side had much of good-faith activity in them, and both side focused on the worst participants from the other side, primarily those that did misogyny and misandry.
Re:Fandom Is Broken by tptacek on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @12:23PM (#11815707)
Are there warring bands of trolls on the Internet latching on to either side of any controversy? Yes.

Does that change the fact that people who self-identify as "GamerGaters" are overwhelmingly likely to be the same people carrying on about the evils of "feminism" on message boards? No, it does not.

Hence, my original comment.