News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by pnut on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:35PM (#11809483)
I did really well in school, and am a professional developer now, and my wife utterly destroys me at this game.

She can find sets in real time as the cards are being dealt, while singing along with music, it's maddening.

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by dhekir on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:14PM (#11809817)
Could it be somehow related to better peripheral vision?

I met a woman once who could gather four-leaf clovers nearly instantly, at the same spot where me and my male friends had spent minutes searching.

I've seen written in some places (but could not find a worthy source) that women might have better peripheral vision due to food gathering in prehistoric times, but this might just be some old sexist construct (if anyone knows a good source to confirm or refute this, please tell me).

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by mundo on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:37PM (#11810825)
Funny anecdata: in my circle of friends, the trait that best predicts Set skill isn't IQ or gender or anything like that, it's musical ability.

This came up at a party. Six people playing Set, all of us from different cities, and the three that took band in high school utterly dominated the three that didn't. The reason? Field trips. The Band kids had all played Set for hours on buses, the rest of us had only played it once or twice and lost interest.

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by function_seven on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @08:32PM (#11811344)
I like how you introduce a correlating attribute in the beginning of your comment, get me thinking about the relationship between musical ability and set-identifying ability, then clobber whatever hypothesis I was putting together just as fast with the confounding "field trips" variable.

Nice work :)

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by mundo on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @12:18PM (#11815667)
Thank you! I should be writing clickbait headlines.

"Will this STUNNING mathematical breakthrough in a children's card game finally make Kim leave Kanye?"

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by tamana on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @01:01AM (#11812151)
But why is set so popular on band trips, but not football trips?
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by function_seven on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @10:23AM (#11814542)
I'd guess that the players on a football team would be reviewing the playbook all the way up until kickoff. Meanwhile the band isn't going to be practicing their performance on the bus.
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by imglorp on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:48PM (#11810097)
I bet it's closer to the pattern matching part of the brain that counts objects at a glance. This is a different skill than counting with words.
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by theoh on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @05:02PM (#11810209)
From https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subitizing

"Subitizing is the rapid, accurate, and confident judgement of numbers performed for small numbers of items. [...] The accuracy, speed, and confidence with which observers make judgments of the number of items are critically dependent on the number of elements to be enumerated. Judgments made for displays composed of around one to four items are rapid, accurate and confident."

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by lettergram on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:41PM (#11810035)
I don't know if that's a male/female trait. I literally find four leaf clovers so often/fast that I don't even consciousnessly know how I do it. I'll just reach down and grab them.

I'm a male btw

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by tgb on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @05:12PM (#11810287)
As a kid I would find them all the time. These days if I end up standing around a clover patch with nothing to do, I always look for them but never find them. I can't imagine I had the patience to look for them as a kid for very long, so I feel that my ability must have gone down hill OR that the patches I'm by now just don't have as many of them. I was always convinced that the ones at the house I grew up at had an abundance of four (or higher) leafed clovers and that patches at school, for example, were relatively poor.

Perhaps that ability decline is just my current reluctance to get down on my hands and knees and leaf through them by hand.

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by lowtolerance on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @09:33AM (#11814170)
My mother is like this with four-leaf clovers. We can be walking together and having a conversation, and she'll stop mid-stride and pick up a four-leaf clover that any normal person would have had to stop and hunt for. I definitely did not inherit this skill - I can't recall ever having found one.
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by xom on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @12:02PM (#11815504)
quoting https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10954918 :

> Go players activate the brain region of vision, and literally think by seeing the board state. A lot of Go study is seeing patterns and shapes... 4-point bend is life, or Ko in the corner, Crane Nest, Tiger Mouth, the Ladder... etc. etc.

> Go has probably been so hard for computers to "solve" not because Go is "harder" than Chess (it is... but I don't think that's the primary reason), but instead because humans brains are innately wired to be better at Go than at Chess. The vision-area of the human's brain is very large, and "hacking" the vision center of the brain to make it think about Go is very effective.

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by oh_sigh on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:46PM (#11810871)
My girlfriend is amazing at finding 4 leaf clovers, but I destroy her in Set...so they may not be related skills
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by hinkley on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:44PM (#11809555)
Our friend is so jarringly good at Set and Scrabble that nobody will play with her anymore. She has to play people on the internet and they frequently disconnect mid-match.
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by Nadya on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @05:57PM (#11810616)
If you want to lose friends and be disowned from your family - learn to play Monopoly by the actual rules and follow this strategy: http://imgur.com/a/vX3zm

I can confirm that it works and nobody wants to play Monopoly anymore. Instead we play more fun board games

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by tamana on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @01:10AM (#11812175)
This strategy works when one person plays by the complicated rules and everyone else plays for fun. When you go pull out some BGG game, you'll have the same problem: the board game geek rules lawyer playing strategy and trouncing players who play for fun.
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by chongli on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @03:21AM (#11812623)
This is why it's better to go to a YouTube channel like Rahdo Runs Through [0] than BGG's ranking page. Rahdo plays with his wife and they prefer games with a lower interaction level than the typical BGG forum power user. This means strategies based on blocking the other players' access to the resources they need are not included or emphasized in the games they play.

Though you will find exceptions, of course. The current number one game on BGG is Pandemic Legacy [1], a purely cooperative game.

[0] https://youtube.com/user/rahdo

[1] https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/161936/pandemic-legacy-s...

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by Nadya on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @11:16AM (#11815002)
To be fair - Monopoly is a partially luck-based strategy game. And while having fun is certainly a big part of board games - so is winning and winning is pretty fun for most people.

I see it as a split between "casuals" and "competitive" players. Competitive players find fun in attempting to win or giving it their best shot while casual players see winning as a bonus and just want to have fun. Which may or may not involve playing with the best strategies or giving it their best.

I also agree entirely with lmm. The best games are games that are fun even when losing. If you can't have fun while losing (eg: Monopoly) then I don't consider it a good game.

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by PeterisP on Friday June 03, 2016 @02:09PM (#11832088)
Monopoly is a particular case where it's important to play with the actual rules if you play for fun - the common deviations from the rules make the game much, much more drawn out than intended, beyond the point where everything is already decided but you get to slowly slog it out through the motions and it becomes boring. "As intended", monopoly has a rather rapid endgame after the (arguably more fun) initial and middle part.
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by lmm on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @06:06AM (#11813256)
In any competitive game the majority of players will be losing. So a good game is one that's fun even when you're losing.
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by rconti on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @11:03PM (#11811828)
That's awesome, thanks. Also introduced me to Georgism which I naturally relate to Piketty. Now I've got a lot of reading to do.
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by knodi123 on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:42PM (#11810043)
> and they frequently disconnect mid-match.

Speaking solely of scrabble, this happens pretty often regardless of skill level. ;-) I try to keep 3 games going at a time, but my last 5 have quit in the first three turns! And I'm using a matchmaking algorithm, so they're players of my approximate skill level too!

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by cwmoo740 on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @05:31PM (#11810435)
My family is ultra-competitive and this used to be one of our go to games until my sister mastered it. My brother-in-law wrote an android game to help her practice and after about a month she was down to sub 1 minute clears. We had to give up the game after that.
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by natdempk on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @07:11PM (#11810996)
Is the android app available for download anywhere?
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by cwmoo740 on Thursday June 02, 2016 @05:55PM (#11826417)
He got a cease and desist from the manufacturer so he took it down unfortunately.
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by Agentlien on Wednesday June 01, 2016 @05:23AM (#11813085)
I'm also a professional software engineer who did very well in high school and at the university and, similarly, my wife consistently beats me at this type of games.

Granted, my wife is well-educated and I believe she is smarter than I am, but it's like she immediately sees the solution while I see the input and have to work out the solution. I usually attribute this to my deficient color vision, since that's the property that usually trips me up. Alternatively, I've wondered if I'm focusing too hard and if the best approach might be reacting on instinct and relying on my subconscious to solve the problem before I'm consciously aware of having parsed the input.

Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by exacube on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:38PM (#11809500)
there are many forms of intelligence!
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by treehau5 on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:41PM (#11810033)
Reminds me of Sir Ken Robinson's TED talk
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by matwood on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:48PM (#11810096)
Sounds like she would be an amazing NFL QB if she can also throw a football :)
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by pmichaud on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @06:55PM (#11810920)
My wife also is amazing at this game and destroys me every time :)
Re:Simple Set Game Proof Stuns Mathematicians by jackhack on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @05:39PM (#11810495)
Synesthesia? Perhaps her brain sees those sets and identifies them in such a way that it takes no conscious effort? A group might appear in a different color, or "taste" or feeling, for example...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synesthesia