News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by guelo on Monday May 30, 2016 @06:42PM (#11803635)
What's ironic about Thiel attacking Gawker for, supposedly, being bad tabloid journalists is that as a Trump delegate he is supporting someone that has frequently polluted our highest political discourse with tabloid-level internet conspiracy theories. To Thiel personal smears are more troublesome than a well functioning democracy. But then he has in the past already expressed his contempt of democracy so I guess it should not come as a surprise.
Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by whack on Monday May 30, 2016 @08:34PM (#11803958)
I don't get people's need to constantly bring up Thiel's support for Trump, as though it singularly defines him and everything else he does. In this case, his suing Gawker has nothing whatsoever to do with him supporting Trump. Those are 2 completely independent issues, and should be treated as such. Someone could support Trump for a whole bunch of (stupid) reasons that have nothing to do with libel lawsuits, and it's time we stopped conflating these 2 unrelated topics.
Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by fpgeek on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:12PM (#11804323)
Thiel suing Gawker has is absolutely related to his Trump support. Trump is the presidential candidate who wants to "open up those libel laws" to make it easier to sue the press. It is certainly notable that one of Trump's prominent supports has pushed the boundaries of existing laws in the service of similar goals.

In the other direction, Thiel's Trump support suggests that his funding of Gawker lawsuits isn't just about Gawker and his history with them (which is how many people defend Thiel's actions, describing Gawker as an unusually bad actor that is reaping what they sowed). Instead, it suggests that the Gawker lawsuits are indicative of his broader attitudes about how the press should behave and what consequences there should be for press that doesn't.

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by parennoob on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:25PM (#11804360)
> Thiel suing Gawker

I think this tends to be papered over too much with "yeah yeah, it's the same thing", but Thiel is not suing Gawker.

Thiel is bankrolling a lawsuit against Gawker related to its publishing videos of someone being naked without their consent, an issue that in the case of Erin Andrews led to a $55 million award and widespread public sympathy (http://abcnews.go.com/US/erin-andrews-jury-set-deliberate-75...).

Whatever you feel about the Hulk Hogan lawsuit against Gawker is wrong, ask yourself if you would you would feel the same way in the Erin Andrews case.

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by wtbob on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @08:58AM (#11806253)
> I don't get people's need to constantly bring up Thiel's support for Trump, as though it singularly defines him and everything else he does.

It's an ad hominem fallacy: Thiel supports Trump, ergo his assistance to Hulk Hogan is foolish.

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by guelo on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:34PM (#11807558)
I made a point and you guys chose to ignore it in order to say my argument was a fallacy.

The point was that as a Trump supporter Thiel is OK with using false conspiracy theories to manipulate the public.

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by cronjobber on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @04:39AM (#11805433)
It has been hypothesized that our brain's moral systems are a highjack of systems related to hygiene.

I think this phenomenon shows it nicely. Since Thiel has "touched" Trump, he is now "unclean" in the minds of people who perceive Trump through their morality circuits.

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by internaut on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @11:25AM (#11807071)
Yes. And they will proceed further along those lines later on by monitoring all his associations.

Nick Denton said as much "The details of your involvement will be gruesome if you continue suing us".

Sounds like a threat to me.

Thiel surely knows this but he's no coward. If I was him I'd have kept everything a secret. He must have weighted the probability of getting his funding discovered and then attacked by the Media Tribe against the (positive) deterrence factor plus being researched by (negative) private investigators i.e. blackmail efforts.

It is ironic that the chilling effects argument would push him into more clandestine arrangements (it's a sinister cabal!). You can't make people happy these days. Far from a billionaire having more rights than the average person, the Media is really arguing they have less rights than the average person i.e. He shouldn't have funded Hogan openly or privately; that is not at all. Presumably if the average person decided to pull together a public fund for their hero Hulk Hogan it wouldn't be a problem.

Nick Denton is not a very astute person. Just like in an ecosystem the foxes can't meaningfully 'win' against the rabbits. Some of the rich and powerful I know of would just have outright killed him for toying with them. Denton is depending on the morality of the people he attacks and that is not a very smart thing to do in the long run. That's not me being bombastic or making weird implicit threat. It is an observation of the reality for journalists around the world, the CPJ knows that very intimately. The irony is that if Thiel wasn't a supporter of the CPJ, didn't have strong convictions, then perhaps he'd be less likely to get attacked by the likes of Gawker.

If Gawker ever went after real targets Denton would be joining something like the Ecuadorian Embassy. That is a fact.

That's why we should be supporting real journalists and not this poser.

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by guelo on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:37PM (#11807583)
Thank you for the psychoanalysis. However, I made a specific, logical point about how in another context Thiel is OK with the use of false facts to manipulate the public. It was not a moral or emotional argument.
Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by pm24601 on Monday May 30, 2016 @07:41PM (#11803816)
Thiel's approach is scary. He is basically proving that he doesn't have to win - he just has to consume enough of a media company's money to force them out of business.

Many major stories that made it big in the national news start off as a local or small paper doing the initial reporting. (For example the Flint, Mi lead water) These papers have such tiny budgets that they can easily be silenced.

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by chimeracoder on Monday May 30, 2016 @08:21PM (#11803915)
> He is basically proving that he doesn't have to win - he just has to consume enough of a media company's money to force them out of business

That's theoretically true - after all, it's the same way patent trolling works. But he hasn't actually proven that yet, since he did win a juried verdict (with punitive damages, on top of that).

That's about as clear-cut a decision as our legal system can provide (before getting to the appellate level).

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by PlainsWight on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @03:46PM (#11809577)
To be fair, this is the only one of his suits against Gawker that he's disclosed having funded, so it's quite difficult to judge their overall merits.
Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by theoracle101 on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:31AM (#11804575)
How is this any different than Gawker using the legal system as a defense strategy? They print whatever they want, and good luck suing them, they'll wear you out in long legal battles with their deep pockets.

The only difference this time is they picked on a bully with bigger pockets.

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by internaut on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:44PM (#11808391)
I've seen this question asked about a dozen times now on HN and nobody is even attempting to answer it.

It's all handwaving madly so the flaws in their reasoning aren't spotted. That remains my position until a good argument gets presented that isn't all over the place with logic leaps.

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by CyberDildonics on Monday May 30, 2016 @10:06PM (#11804171)
Did you read the article? That is how tabloids end up printing false stories about people and defending themselves.
Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by brc on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:45AM (#11804861)
That is the whole point of punitive damages though. The big awards are a punishment of the person or company which lose.

Plenty of environmentalists would be happy if an oil company got sued into bankruptcy over a spill.

It's the way of the courts, really.

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by powertower on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @01:28AM (#11804793)
> Trump ... has frequently polluted our highest political discourse with tabloid-level internet conspiracy theories.

If I'm reading your statement correctly...

I've listened to some of Trump's speeches, and also the mainstream media's constant misrepresentation of them.

Would you mind sharing how Trump is polluting our "highest political discourse"?

Re:How the Supermarket Tabloids Stay Out of Court (1991) by guelo on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @12:45PM (#11807667)