News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Does It Mean to Be Poor in Germany? by weinzierl on Sunday May 29, 2016 @12:22AM (#11794765)
>...free/heavily subsidized daycare, tax incentives, and maybe even payments.

We have all of this in Germany.

Child care is not free but heavily subsidized, even more there is a right to child care for children from age one to six [1].

Tax reductions are more complicated, broadly speaking the tax exempt amount for every child is around 7000 EUR - not too bad [2 (in German, look for the table in the section "Höhe des Kinderfreibetrages")] .

Payments "Child benefit" are [3]:

    1 Child	        184 EUR/month
    2 Children          386 EUR/month
    3 Children	        558 EUR/month
    additional child    215 EUR/month
The source has a comparison with other countries and while difficult to compare I think Germany is in the top.

[1] https://www.deutschland.de/en/topic/politics/germany-europe/...

[2] http://www.kindergeld.org/kinderfreibetrag.html

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_benefit

Re:What Does It Mean to Be Poor in Germany? by mduerksen on Sunday May 29, 2016 @04:39AM (#11795533)
Tax reductions are set against the payments though, so only really well earning parents actually benefit from them.

I suspect the reasons are more social ones. Examples:

Having children is not being valued highly, having a career is. Imagine a woman proudly announcing to some gala aquaintances that she has 4 children. In a lot of countries, this would be the norm. In Germany, the woman would be deemed low-class.

Lack of family cohesion, thus as a parent, you are on your own. Compare this to the luxury of letting the grandparents take care of the kids multiple times a week/month.

Consumerism. A German thinks he has to have it all. Kids are percieved as a threat to that. We are very good at making our own lives miserable by not valuing family and friends over having the newest car/stereo/boat.

Perfectionsm. Parents think they have to get everything right and only the best things for their kids (again, THINGS). And the society thinks the same - a mother should be perfectly dressed, handling her two perfectly dressed kids with ease and loving devotion 24/7, never just let them play on their own but instead already teaching them latin. AND of course, having a stellar career AND a slender waist at the same time.

Re:What Does It Mean to Be Poor in Germany? by Certhas on Sunday May 29, 2016 @06:29AM (#11795833)
I agree to some extend, but I don't think this explains the low birth rate compared to other very similar countries like France, the UK or the US, where many of the things you describe apply equally or in greater measure.

An aspect that seems more uniquely German is looking down on mothers that give their child to daycare "too early", meaning, before it's 3 years old.

Anecdotally from conversations with friends in their mid late twenties, early thirties, the idea that you have to justify yourself as a woman, or somehow fail as a mother, if you start working again too soon is still very prominent.

Re:What Does It Mean to Be Poor in Germany? by Gmo on Sunday May 29, 2016 @12:09PM (#11796845)
This is definitely true (not German, but with a German SO and a German sister-in-law ...)
Re:What Does It Mean to Be Poor in Germany? by mduerksen on Sunday May 29, 2016 @08:43AM (#11796169)
Yes, thats one aspect of the perfectionism I was talking about.
Re:What Does It Mean to Be Poor in Germany? by y4mi on Sunday May 29, 2016 @07:35AM (#11795982)
> Having children is not being valued highly, having a career is. Imagine a woman proudly announcing to some gala aquaintances that she has 4 children. In a lot of countries, this would be the norm. In Germany, the woman would be deemed low-class.

i was amazed reading this. there are nations where the natives are proud of beeing breeders?

while its not something to be ashamed of, it most certainly not something you should be proud of either...

Re:What Does It Mean to Be Poor in Germany? by mduerksen on Sunday May 29, 2016 @09:10AM (#11796228)
Well, you cannot reduce motherhood to the simple fact that a birth has taken place. That is why it would be pretty offensive to characterize a mother as such.

A woman that has given birth almost certainly has also taken care of the child(ren) for many years, which shows, at least, the ability to:

- master a high responsibility job

- take on a huge workload

- constantly juggle multiple tasks at once

- typically work overtime

- keeping team morale up despite competing needs

- setting goals for the further development of each team member, and keeping a steady eye on the progress that is being made

Sounds like a management job, does it not?

Not to mention the extreme commitment towards everything that accompanies the pregnancy and delivery itself, including, amongst others:

- pain and nausea

- heavy reconfiguration of the body

- strech marks and/or genital wounds

- risk of losing the child

- risk of having a ill or impaired child

- risk of dying

- risk of losing the man and being on your own with all the aforementioned tasks

Yes, a woman with decent kids can most certainly be proud of herself.

Re:What Does It Mean to Be Poor in Germany? by wongarsu on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:56AM (#11801870)
>There are nations where the natives are proud of beeing breeders?

In Israel the average woman has 3 children, and having 3-4 children is expected as the norm in the middle class.

Re:What Does It Mean to Be Poor in Germany? by crucialfelix on Sunday May 29, 2016 @03:44AM (#11795380)
You can also add 14 months of ma/paternity leave (67% of income replaced, max €1800/mo)

Child benefit (Kindergeld) goes until the age of 18

Re:What Does It Mean to Be Poor in Germany? by weinzierl on Sunday May 29, 2016 @03:56AM (#11795428)
> You can also add 14 months of ma/paternity leave (67% of income replaced, max €1800/mo)

Yes, and it's a right, your employer can't refuse it. If I remember correctly the 14 months is only if both parents take part, 12 months otherwise. 12 months for the wife, 2 months for the husband is typical.

> Child benefit (Kindergeld) goes until the age of 18

Even until 25 if your children have no income of their own, e.g. when they are go to college.

Re:What Does It Mean to Be Poor in Germany? by crucialfelix on Monday May 30, 2016 @11:33AM (#11801761)
There is a confusing but splendid program called elterngeld-plus. You take half time (25-30 std/wo) and get half money but for twice as long.

If both partners take it at the same time for 4 parallel months then you receive a bonus 4 months (which you can also take as half time which means 8 months). You could theoretically get 28 months of half-money/half-time.