It was never a rule against making comparisons to Hitler, it was an observation that people will do it.
Your people that are arguing it doesn't apply should be saying it's more true than ever or something.
2. Mike Godwin himself says that comparing Trump to Hitler is justifiable. https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/12/14/...
3. Usually when I see comparisons of Trump to Hitler, and discussions of whether that comparison is defensible, there's rarely any discussion of how the "present day" changes anything. Godwin does make the point that in 2015, we now have the capability to question poor arguments more effectively. But I've seen basically no arguments that the world is fundamentally different from the past, just that Trump is a fundamentally different demagogue from those we've seen since 1946.
(Or are you claiming that Mike Godwin doesn't actually mean the things that the Washington Post published under his name?)
The other reasoning given from our fellow peers that I have heard sounds like that this law was made during the era of quiet bulletin boards, made up of people with a shared mind set, with a shared sense of humour, and the Internet now has changed beyond recognition. Therefore any laws made about the internet back then have no validity.
I would like to suggest that when you consider something no longer valid it could give you pause to think about your reasonings for doing so.