News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by WalterBright on Friday May 27, 2016 @07:47PM (#11789868)
> rather than hoarding it

Nobody hoards cash. It's all invested, one way or another. Even 'cash on deposit' is invested in that the bank loans it out. The idea that cash is withheld from the economy is incorrect.

What's happening here is the cash is getting invested in foreign economies rather than local ones, not that it is being withheld or "hoarded".

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by rtpg on Friday May 27, 2016 @07:54PM (#11789909)
> Even 'cash on deposit' is invested in that the bank loans it out.

If you combine this with the fact that banks work on fractional reserves, then there'd end up being infinite money... but there isn't because it's not true. Of course banks _do_ give out loans, but they're not at 100%. And there are capital limits and the like...

Look at Japan. Why do you think the central bank is at negative interest rates is because banks aren't loaning out money. Or they are but companies aren't spending the money, which basically comes out to the same thing, minus a credit subsidy.

I think if you dig deeper into this problem, you'll find both that there's a decent inflow into banks that don't have corresponding outflow.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by gozur88 on Friday May 27, 2016 @10:08PM (#11790297)
>If you combine this with the fact that banks work on fractional reserves, then there'd end up being infinite money... but there isn't because it's not true.

In practical terms the only limit to the amount of new money is the amount qualified borrowers are willing to borrow. Banks that don't have enough reserves typically borrow from other banks or from the central bank. The central bank (in the US, at least) isn't bound by reserve limits at all and can create money by changing a number in a computer.

The lack of lending by banks isn't a problem in and of itself. It's a symptom of the underlying problem, which is a lack of economic activity that would require borrowing.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by WalterBright on Friday May 27, 2016 @08:19PM (#11789996)
I do know about fractional reserve banking, and know that the government requires a minimum reserve percentage. The banks holding a percentage required by law is not an instance of corporations hoarding cash.

The reason banks offer free checking is so they can get your money on deposit and then make money loaning it out back into the economy. They aren't offering free checking because they are being charitable.

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by jonbarker on Friday May 27, 2016 @09:47PM (#11790253)
These companies are not banks so I am not sure why we are talking about cash on deposit. Cash that exists on a corporate balance sheet for a non bank company really only exists to reduce risk of default on obligations or prepare for a cash investment of some kind. Not an accountant but can't think of any other use of cash.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by WalterBright on Friday May 27, 2016 @11:14PM (#11790451)
> why we are talking about cash on deposit

Because the companies do not have cash hoards. They put cash in a bank. The bank loans the money out to people who spend it.

The idea that corporations are Smaugs with mountains stuffed with gold coins needing to be liberated by hobbitses and merry bands of dwarves is a fine fairy tail, but is not how modern economies work.

(The amusing thing about Smaug's hoard is it was so ridiculously large that if it was spent by the dwarves, the value of gold would completely collapse to the point where it'd be used to make plumbing.)

Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by jonbarker on Saturday May 28, 2016 @12:43PM (#11792286)
I really like the analogy but Smaugs' gold might track inflation if lucky whereas cash carries inflation risk. A nice problem to have in the realm of "first world problems" for sure but still a problem. Also, if the companies had good enough perceived growth opportunities they would be investing instead of carrying hoardes of cash.
Re:Apple, Microsoft, and Google hold 23% of all U.S. corpora... by WalterBright on Saturday May 28, 2016 @03:16PM (#11792963)
A more or less real world experiment with Smaug's gold happened when the Spanish exploited S. America for gold and silver, shipping it back to Spain.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Price_Revolution

The inference I draw is that prosperity does not stem from adding large quantities of money (gold) to the economy; what happens instead is disruption.