Re:Oracle attorney says Google’s court victory might kill th...
by Nomentatus on Friday May 27, 2016 @07:48PM
(#11789878)
Agreed. This attorney is conflating code and API, but it's not at all clear that the jury did.
Re:Oracle attorney says Google’s court victory might kill th...
by protomyth on Sunday May 29, 2016 @10:57AM
(#11796564)
Yeah, the argument presented seems to go way beyond the case, but I do have a bit of a concern.
If using the API is fair use, how does this affect programs using libraries licensed under the GPL? Can a company claim fair use and not follow the GPL's restrictions on linking?
Re:Oracle attorney says Google’s court victory might kill th...
by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday May 31, 2016 @11:58AM
(#11807286)
> If using the API is fair use, how does this affect programs using libraries licensed under the GPL?
If you use the library, you're using - executing - the implementation, not just the interface. That's not covered by this case, and you can't ignore the GPL's restriction on linking.
The analogy of this case would be if you kept the same function signatures of the library, but re-implemented it. Can you do that without violating the GPL? This case says "yes".
Ahem. No, it's just your flawed legal idea that's falling. Code is still totally copyrightable, and not takeable under "fair use" (unless it's a very small amount), but using APIs is fair use.
API != implementation. Is that so hard to understand?