I also like the idea of showing someone's profile photo only after they book. Really, there is no reason for anyone to see my photos for short-term rentals.
Maybe the two could be tied together! That is, if I start canceling prior availability dates more than a couple times, AirBNB will stop showing me profile pictures of prospective tenants in advance.
Also to +1 the general topic from my (female) Asian perspective which is typically considered rather non-threatening, I have a pretty vanilla photo and I always bring up "nice" things when inquiring about airbnbs, if there are no instant book options. The profiling adds up to a serious load of crap especially when you get to a/b test a bit by asking someone else to also inquire about the place.
Yes, you have to make effort to show that you are not going to trash my house. Its not a hotel.
If you don't want strangers in your house --- and I sure don't either --- don't try to capitalize on it on Airbnb.
I have a very expensive permit ($2300 for the first year) and jumped through all the hoops. We pay occupancy tax, etc.
What makes it most different from a hotel is that we have to vet our guests. We won't take anyone off the street. This is perfectly reasonable and also different from a hotel.
I do hope that cities avoid passing laws around vacation rentals. The law is our town is an expensive illogical nightmare.
Additionally potential renters should be able to rate this initial experience as well, which should factor in the rating.
Dont think that will fix this problem but might curtail some of this behavior. I believe that technology and applied correctly has potential of changing behaviors (we have seen that in spades with AirBnB already).