2) This patent troll is an NPE, which is usually (along with, you know, suing) the defining trait of patent trolldom. Why are you reciting grade-school nostrums about the Noble Idea of IP protection in general when responding to news about a particular entity in a particular case, who is quite clearly a troll? If I'm missing something, do clue me in.
3) If I'm misreading you, please do clarify. Being specific about harm, to whom, exactly, you're referring when bashing "the media", and perhaps why an extremely simplistic defense of patents seemed needed here would all be edifying.
Look at Goodyear. He was an NPE. He invented vulcanized rubber. Never saw a dime. They even stole his name and built a company around it. He didn't have the resources to sue.
Look at Robert Kearns. He was an NPE. He sued. It destroyed his life.
There's no special qualification to come up with an idea. Patenting is a painful process. But it's a way to protect yourself. Just because people are involved in a lawsuit doesn't say or mean anything.
Regardless, this company is not an NPE. They have a working implementation of their secure messaging patent that is available on the app store.
> In what way is it "doing harm" to the patent system?
It's doing harm by framing inventors as villains rather than innovators. You've judged this company based on no other information than that they are referred to as patent trolls in an online article. If it's that easy for a large company to quell innovators, then the purpose of patents in the first place - to foster innovation - is gone.
--- Regardless the verbiage is frequently inappropriate and certainly in this instance.
Well here's a study showing that the user of the term "troll" had become widely used by media without any evidence to support their negative views. This has led to judges forbidding the use of that term at trials as it is unfairly prejudicial.
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2768939
If it is improper in the court of law, one can reasonably assume it is improper in the court of public opinion as well. The effects of this bias can be seen in the usual comments on patent-related threads here and other forums, where the USPTO is regularly derided by people who don't know the first thing about patents. These people know only what the media tells them, and as the paper shows, media is highly biased. This bias is being spread to a large audience and is also being used to push for reform that may not necessarily be balanced. I'd say, yes, such rhetoric is hurting the patent system.
Hilarious joke man!
Would you spend millions in developing something novel just to have some random with a capriciously granted "X, but on a computer" drag you through court?
citation needed. another interpretation of the law is that it was designed to reward companies commensurate to the size of their legal department.
"To promote progress" is the core rationale for this power; I would argue that if the current implemention no longer does that, or in fact inhibits progress, then Congress needs to redefine how this works in law.
No, the patent system was dedigned to elevate Queen's friends above their competition.
> By the 16th century, the English Crown would habitually grant letters patent for monopolies to favoured persons (or people who were prepared to pay for them).[14] [...]
> This power was used to raise money for the Crown, and was widely abused, as the Crown granted patents in respect of all sorts of common goods (salt, for example).
The other problem is that the protections offered by patents were designed at to give a "temporary monopoly" on the invention at hand. For software patents, though, this "temporary monopoly" ends up being (sometimes) five times the lifetime of that given technology. This is partly because the barriers for "inventing" something in the software space are minimal. Cloud hosting for services makes it possible for a small inventor to provide a large service inexpensively (or, at least without large upfront expenses). Traditional software requires only time and a place to download. What happens with software patents is the "inventor" is effectively given a monopoly over more than the effective lifetime of the product and for reasons that don't fit with the original design of the patent system.
Then there's the relative "quality" of those patents. Patents are supposed to be a way to make an invention public so that a person skilled in the field is able to reproduce the invention from the patent, alone. That's laughable if you've read any of the kinds of patents that end up in this kind of litigation. The patent is written in an artform designed to make the description of the invention as vague as possible (to cover as much infringement as possible) and is accepted by an overworked patent office that doesn't have people skilled in the field enough to actually evaluate whether a patent application should be accepted and granted this temporary-turned-lifetime monopoly protection.
These facts are what are doing harm to the patent system and it's no surprise, to me. I am not anti-patent[1]. I believe the protections as they were intended are a good idea. They're being abused, horribly, these days and the system around it needs to be brought back to its roots. Inventions with large barriers to production (drugs, where it can cost an incredible amount of money to get through regulatory approvals, for instance) should be allowed reasonable lengths of time for monopoly protections to encourage their development[2], but things that are novel, and have little-to-no barriers to production should have extremely limited or no protection from the patent system and trolling in this manner should come with penalties (plaintiff pays).
[1] OK, I'm vehemently against software patents and I have a serious problem with gene patents (I can't patent a rock, or the definition of the characteristics of a rock, I shouldn't be able to patent the characteristics of a molecule,... it's an over-simplification, but that's my opinion on the subject).
[2] There's plenty wrong here, too, but it's the best example I could come up with.
The patent system was designed to foster innovation. If you invent something, you get protection for your intellectual property. It's not a requirement that you produce a product. You could realize that you don't have the resources right out of the gate and choose to license your invention to someone that does. The days of submarine patents are over.
There are some entities that actually are patent trolls - companies that collect patents for litigation purposes - but just because a lawsuit happens doesn't mean that the plaintiff is a patent troll.