News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by slg on Thursday May 26, 2016 @06:40PM (#11782263)
The article doesn't touch on it, but the obvious followup question from the laymen is why can't we develop new antibiotics? I was curious and according to Wikipedia we haven't developed a new class of antibiotics in 30+ years. Can someone with knowledge on the subject explain why we seemingly can't discover/develop new forms of antibiotics to combat these resistant bugs?
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by Fomite on Thursday May 26, 2016 @09:10PM (#11783159)
A couple issues:

1. It's hard. You need to find a molecule that has a mechanism of action against bacteria, but only bacteria. Any cellular function you share with human cells is right out (this is why anti-fungals are double-plus hard mode). We got away with this by glueing new functional groups onto things to evade resistance, but inventing a new target never before seen in nature is...tricky. Most of the easy stuff got developed by the bacteria first - they've been working on this problem longer than we have.

2. It's very expensive. Fidaxomicin (aka Difficid) cost $175 million to develop, and it's on the cheaper side. While it might still be profitable, that's a steep up-front cost. One does not casually embark on developing a new antibiotic.

Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by FooBarWidget on Thursday May 26, 2016 @06:54PM (#11782345)
From what I have read, the problem is that antibiotic development is not profitable. If a new antibiotic gets developed then it will be out on the shelf as a last-resort antibiotic, preventing the developing company from extracting a lot of revenue. And it is more profitable to develop drugs for chronic diseases. So pharmaceutic companies don't bother with antibiotics.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by gooserock on Thursday May 26, 2016 @10:53PM (#11783565)
...displaying a great example of why the free market is not the best way to handle healthcare and medical research. The availability of treatment has everything to do with profit, and little to do with need.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by mobilefriendly on Thursday May 26, 2016 @11:47PM (#11783778)
Given the heavy involvement of the state in funding and directing care and research, I don't think anyone would describe healthcare and medical research as a free market.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by TallGuyShort on Friday May 27, 2016 @09:55AM (#11786022)
Yeah but that's more because of lobbying and politics than logical, economic approaches to problems. It's not like when I go to the doctor everyone's incentives are aligned. The insurance company is still actively working against me, just now it's really complicated how they do it due to regulation so only they can play the game and I just have to take their decision until it's worth getting lawyers involved.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by TeMPOraL on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:36AM (#11784674)
Indeed, and that's because free market dynamics are incompatibile with healthcare in obvious and predictable ways.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by logicchains on Friday May 27, 2016 @12:52AM (#11783973)
It's more profitable to develop drugs for chronic diseases because there are a lot more people with chronic diseases than there are people with infections only treatable by antibiotics of last resort, hence there is a lot more need for drugs that treat chronic diseases than there is need for last-resort antibiotics.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by crpatino on Thursday May 26, 2016 @08:57PM (#11783101)
For the same reason we cannot close one bug per developer per day.

At first you can do it, then, all the easy ones get solved. The ones that remain all have a number of troubles: they are hard to reproduce, or the last person to touch that module quit last September, or that's a known issues with the architecture that has been put off for the last 2 releases, etc, etc.

Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by xkcd-sucks on Thursday May 26, 2016 @06:59PM (#11782378)
The problem is similar to making rat poison that's safe to eat, e.g. it's fundamentally tricky.

Add to that the usual problems with drug discovery+development, e.g. stuff that works in a dish doesn't always work when critters eat it.

Add the problem that new antibiotics should be used only when necessary, e.g. you won't sell a lot of product until it's really old and off patent

Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by fleitz on Thursday May 26, 2016 @07:23PM (#11782524)
No, it's nothing like rat poison because bacteria cellular pathways are a more different than eurakayotic cellular pathways. This is why most antibiotics work against many bacteria just as rat poison works on most mammals.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by jinfiesto on Thursday May 26, 2016 @06:52PM (#11782336)
AFAIK, the main issue is that we don't know how to cultivate very many kinds of bacteria (relative to the number of species there are.) Since antibiotics are a by-product of bacteria, the number of antibiotics we can effectively produce are limited to the antibiotics produced by species of bacteria that we can effectively cultivate.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by crimsonalucard on Thursday May 26, 2016 @06:55PM (#11782352)
I thought the main issue was that it wasn't profitable enough.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by TeMPOraL on Friday May 27, 2016 @04:41AM (#11784695)
This is a tricky thing. "Not being profitable enough" isn't always a petty reasoning. With today's technology and science levels, you can do almost anything you can imagine - if you can get enough minds, hands and resources into the project, which is equivalent to throwing enough money at it. Technological advance today is really less about discovering new things and more about making everything easier and cheaper - so that projects that were previously too expensive become cheap enough to tackle.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by fleitz on Thursday May 26, 2016 @07:25PM (#11782535)
That's vaccines and there are regulatory issues in the US with them, antibiotics are perfectly profitable.

Also, only in the US does profitability seem to affect making basic medicines. Bacterial resistance is a global issue, not just one like vaccines that is largely a US issue.

Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by refurb on Thursday May 26, 2016 @08:14PM (#11782872)
Antibiotics aren't generally that profitable in the US. The first reason is antibiotic stewardship: make a really great antibiotic and nobody wants to use it unless they have to. The other reason is that the way antibiotics are reimbursed in the hospital setting prevents charging a price that makes it all that profitable.
Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by reasonattlm on Thursday May 26, 2016 @09:16PM (#11783187)
http://www.popsci.com/ichip-new-way-find-antibiotics-and-oth...

We're going to be flooded with new antibiotics in the years ahead.

Re:Person carrying bacteria resistant to antibiotics of last... by fleitz on Thursday May 26, 2016 @07:21PM (#11782518)
99% of bacteria/fungi don't grow in labs, limiting which antibiotics we can discover.

Luckily, someone thought to grow them in dirt, and now there are many promising new antibiotics.