No court has ever addressed the question. This post is still mostly current (in 2015, USA FREEDOM codified ranges similar to those discussed): https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/04/warrant-canary-faq
As far as we know Reddit did not face any legal consequences when they activated their canary.
I think it's reasonable to speculate that their canary might as well have not existed for the purposes of determining legal consequence. Without the expected uproar over an agency forcing a canary down, the agency has no reason to apply legal pressure on the company. Thus, reddit's canary gives you no real information about the likely reaction of a govt agency to the practice, and certainly no information about a court's view on its legality.
Re:Canary Watch, One Year Later
by fucking_tragedy on Thursday May 26, 2016 @02:27AM
(#11775997)
I'd love to see the same. I'm having a hard time understanding why signaling that a gag order exists with the removal of a canary wouldn't violate the gag order.
Well, you could signal that by failing to renew the canary on schedule. Once there's a gag order, no signaling takes place. There's no "removal".
Right, another name for a canary is a heartbeat, which are used in systems to know if a system is still up:
Right, exactly. A heartbeat. And further, the signing key could be deleted securely, so coercion or spoofing would be impossible. That, however, would be an argumentally illegal action taken after the gag order. One could have an anonymous third party responsible for that. But then they have much power. And the signal to them would also be an argumentally illegal action taken after the gag order.
This is pure speculation/assumption, but I'm guessing it's because the government can't compel someone to lie, or something like that. I have no citations for this, though... It's just what I always assumed when I heard about canaries.
If, on the other hand, the government is allowed to compel someone to lie, I'd really like to know more about that...
Re:Canary Watch, One Year Later
by cloudjacker on Thursday May 26, 2016 @02:10AM
(#11775925)
HAHAHAHAHAHA no man, techies don't know anything about the legal system, you could get them excited about any random concoction aimed at subverting a governmental function.
try it, pretend like it is gospel and they'll build entire business around it just for the rug to be pulled
Anyone able to provide info on this?