Re:How I designed a practical electric plane for a NASA comp...
by paulmd on Thursday May 26, 2016 @12:06AM
(#11775324)
An aircraft can't afford to be hauling around 2-3x as much battery as is actually necessary to fly, as is common in electric cars. I can assure you than when an electric airplane is at the limit of its range, its performance characteristics will change in a negative way.
Electric planes are already at a 100x disadvantage in terms of Specific Energy - liquid fuels (JP-1 jet fuel or gasoline) contain about 46 MJ/kg while Li-ion batteries contain about 0.36-0.875 MJ/kg. They cannot afford to make that a 300x disadvantage. It doesn't work in terms of lift.
As someone else posted in a thread, electric power already takes you from a 900 mile range to a 150 mile range. 50 miles is not acceptable because you're talking <30 minutes of endurance including takeoff, and you have zero safety margin if something should go wrong.
The rest of the stuff thought, yeah that's an issue and I feel like one of the areas where Fuel Cells might actually be applicable(you don't have the long-term leakage/storage/fueling issues as with cars).