News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Foxconn replaces '60,000 factory workers with robots' by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @12:09PM (#11770827)
> But even if those don't happen and you have lowered GDP, a lower GDP is not a bad thing; it's perfectly acceptable, and desirable, for people to spend a smaller fraction of their income.

Lower real GDP doesn't mean lower individual spending, it means lower domestic production of value relative the cost of living.

Lower nominal GDP also doesn't mean lower individual spending, it means lower domestic production in terms of some particular unit of currency, ignoring cost of living.

Both spending and capital investment within the domestic economy (that is, excluding imports), as well as all exports (whether consumer or capital goods) are included in GDP.

> As for your company, if you can reduce costs such that instead of making $50 on each $1000 gadget, you make $100 on each $500 gadget, both you and the consumer of your product win.

But the suppliers of the inputs to the product lose.

> Arguably, GDP seems broken as a metric for not taking that into account.

GDP does take all of that into account, including the parts you ignore.

Re:Foxconn replaces '60,000 factory workers with robots' by JoshTriplett on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @12:50PM (#11771169)
Exports were one of the many things included in "and any number of other factors" (that could cause GDP to not drop in the scenario described in the post I replied to).

The point I was trying to make is that production/GDP alone does not seem like an entirely appropriate metric, if you don't necessarily consider the increased production and consumption (of "gadgets" or otherwise) a universally desirable property. Be careful what you measure and reduce to a numeric metric.

> But the suppliers of the inputs to the product lose.

GDP doesn't include that. GDP includes "final goods and services", not intermediate parts or business-to-business transactions. There are other metrics that include the intermediate steps, if that's desirable.