Re:Comparison of British, American and French Systems of Jus...
by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @11:51AM
(#11770631)
> But what should we do when rehabilitation repeatedly fails for a particular individual?
If the system that is supposed to be rehabilitating people is failing sizable classes of individuals (which is the problem -- not a very few isolated individuals -- that broad three-strikes laws, particularly the pre-reform California version, address), one might consider that the problem is with the design of the system for rehabilitation, and ask how to make that work better, rather than progressively subjecting people for whom it doesn't work to it for longer, and then giving up, the way three strikes laws and other ways of taking post convictions into account in sentencing do.
If the system that is supposed to be rehabilitating people is failing sizable classes of individuals (which is the problem -- not a very few isolated individuals -- that broad three-strikes laws, particularly the pre-reform California version, address), one might consider that the problem is with the design of the system for rehabilitation, and ask how to make that work better, rather than progressively subjecting people for whom it doesn't work to it for longer, and then giving up, the way three strikes laws and other ways of taking post convictions into account in sentencing do.