Re:AMD’s Zen Summit Ridge 8-core CPUs on Par with Intel I7 5...
by vetinari on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @03:53AM
(#11768289)
Quicksync is fine for real-time communication or streaming, not for files where you want maximal visual quality with minimal bits used.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:AMD’s Zen Summit Ridge 8-core CPUs on Par with Intel I7 5...
by cm2187 on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @05:00AM
(#11768509)
It has this bad reputation but in my experience it gives a very decent quality. I may not have stretched the compression ratio too. But at the age of 8TB consumer hard drives...
Re:AMD’s Zen Summit Ridge 8-core CPUs on Par with Intel I7 5...
by jsmthrowaway on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @05:06AM
(#11768540)
It gives a completely and quantifiably awful quality for storage, archival, and typical media center purposes. Transcoding at high efficiency is not what Quick Sync is for. It is for streaming, where it is quite fine. This is known.
I'm not repeating cargo cult science; I benchmarked it because I didn't believe it either (which is good! be suspicious!) and it would have been quite handy for a startup I was developing. But alas. Looks like dogshit or costs too many bits.
Be careful not to confuse "looks fine to me" with quantifiable.
Re:AMD’s Zen Summit Ridge 8-core CPUs on Par with Intel I7 5...
by cm2187 on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @05:15AM
(#11768573)
I guess people have different degrees of tolerance. But I am looking at anandtech's samples:
http://www.anandtech.com/show/7007/intels-haswell-an-htpc-pe...
and I honestly can't see the difference between the QuickSync and regular H264 samples. I am sure there are some tiny subtleties that I miss and perhaps my screen is not good enough to render the difference, but if we are talking about that level of degradation, and unless you are really a purist, the 10x performance gain is really worth it.