News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Just How Profitable Are Healthcare Insurers? by protomyth on Monday March 08, 2010 @05:29PM (#1176687)
If a business makes a profit by serving its customers, I'm ok with that. At this point, given how messed up the health care system is (law, super expensive EOL care, high entry cost for doctors and nurses, poor non-emergency care situation), can you really do the right things. Given the failure of Indian Health Service in serving its customers (to the point of pinning a note that says "we won't pay" on a person transferring to a hospital), I know the government can't even on a loss / non-profit basis.

I almost think the government should start with tuition incentives / loan relief for doctors and nurses, and create a government cataclysmic insurance fund that covers stuff over a $100K (think flood insurance).

Re:Just How Profitable Are Healthcare Insurers? by anamax on Monday March 08, 2010 @06:23PM (#1176839)
> this point, given how messed up the health care system is (law, super expensive EOL care, high entry cost for doctors and nurses, poor non-emergency care situation), can you really do the right things.

Which of those factors are due to insurance companies?

If you don't fix them, how likely is it that any "new" system will be any better?

Re:Just How Profitable Are Healthcare Insurers? by protomyth on Monday March 08, 2010 @06:38PM (#1176885)
Those factors are the landscape the insurance companies operate in. The biggest problem is that I don't see any of the actual legislation doing anything about actual input costs to the system or increasing competition.
Re:Just How Profitable Are Healthcare Insurers? by anamax on Tuesday March 09, 2010 @11:43AM (#1178682)
> The biggest problem is that I don't see any of the actual legislation doing anything about actual input costs to the system or increasing competition.

Not to be rude, but where have you looked?

Besides, if that sort of legislation is what is required, how does its absence justify doing something else?

Re:Just How Profitable Are Healthcare Insurers? by protomyth on Tuesday March 09, 2010 @01:11PM (#1178976)
Well, the last time it was on one of the senator's websites. I admit I was skimming to look if some things were changing for certain currently funded programs, but I kept my eye out for other stuff.

Politics are political. Each party is funded by people who want parts of the current system to stay the same or change for their benefit. Trial Lawyers (D) and Drug Companies (R) for example have huge stakes. I ignore what a politician says and look at the actual documents. I admit, lately, it has been really hard to get ahold of bills. I worry about the urgency that doesn't let a bill be posted and reviewed before voting.

Re:Just How Profitable Are Healthcare Insurers? by anamax on Tuesday March 09, 2010 @04:46PM (#1179482)
> Well, the last time it was on one of the senator's websites.

That's better than nothing, but if you looked at a Repub senator's website, you're unlikely to see all Repub proposals, let alone Dem proposals. The reverse is also true.

> I ignore what a politician says and look at the actual documents. I admit, lately, it has been really hard to get ahold of bills. I worry about the urgency that doesn't let a bill be posted and reviewed before voting.

I agree with all that.

Re:Just How Profitable Are Healthcare Insurers? by protomyth on Tuesday March 09, 2010 @06:31PM (#1179690)
You know, I really don't remember which party, it was a pointer over to the full house's site. This hiding of bills has to stop. It is the information age and I had a lot easier time getting the full text of a bill ten years ago.

I'm just worried everyone is going to have the same "end of fiscal year no money for you" that has plagued the reservations under IHS. The sad part is the coverage of the news media is so poor on these, that the few stories that have gone out are thought of as aberrations instead of the day to day reality. I just wished the gov (both parties) would prove they could get it done with the limited population already served before moving on.

Re:Just How Profitable Are Healthcare Insurers? by anamax on Wednesday March 10, 2010 @11:43AM (#1181285)
> I just wished the gov (both parties) would prove they could get it done with the limited population already served before moving on.

I agree. In fact, that's exactly my proposal - try out nationalized healthcare on federal employees and so on.