They are also, 1% of the time, worth >$100K.
Some people have a tough time valuing volatile assets and end up making statements like this.. "they're not really worth anything" or "treat them like they're $0". But it's utterly wrong to say they have no intrinsic monetary value. It's more correct to call them volatile assets -- or even more correctly, a risk-free (in terms of capital) option to purchase a volatile asset.
In an existing public company, as someone pointed out, the value of the company should be captured by the stock price, according to the efficient market hypothesis. As such, if the price is just as likely to go down as to go up, this should mean that stock options are merely worthless 50% of the time. Before you get into your ability to choose the sale date (subject to trading windows).
So really, unless your public company ONLY goes down from the date you start (excepting really weird scenarios where it goes up, but is always negative relative to your strike price during trading windows), you stand to make money from your options. Maybe not much, but something. And you can't LOSE money from them, unless you do something stupid related to taxes, or something stupid like buy-and-hold. (buy-and-hold for certain values of 'stupid'; I actually did this once in order to swing a lower tax rate and it happened to work, but I could have lost my proverbial shirt).
absolutely does not apply in private-company stock.
As I mentioned, in a private company, it could well be possible that 99% or 97% or whatever of stock options prove to be worthless.
> "Not directly, no. Neither is health insurance, 401k, company provided meals or other benefits, but all of these things are perceived by most to have at least some marginal value."
Stock options are, 99% of the time, worth $0. Perks, benefits, retirement options, all have intrinsic monetary value.