FYI in Ireland where I live GM foods are present in animal feed (or at least they are in the layers pellets I feed my chickens, so I'd guess they're in pretty much all commercially-reared animal products), and therefore there is GM material in the human food chain. It's the same in the UK http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3461226/Most-superma... Maybe there's so much less as to make the US/UK comparison valid, but it's not true to say GM foods are "virtually unknown" in the UK
Re:GMO safety debate is over
by nikolay on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @12:32AM
(#11767674)
Well, mutations on purpose did not pass thousands of years of testing in the environment, also, pairing with pesticides is a problem, too, specifically, glyphosate.
Re:GMO safety debate is over
by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @12:38AM
(#11767692)
Glyphosate is an herbicide, not a pesticide.
And mutations that are random but rapidly through modern non-"GMO" breeding techniques are no more proven by thousands of years than GMOs are, and those developing and deploying them have a lot less knowledge of what changes are induced and what health impacts they may have.
But since they aren't GMOs their apparently okay with the anti-GMO crowd. There is no rational or scientific reason for this.
Re:GMO safety debate is over
by nikolay on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @01:06AM
(#11767758)
The anti-GMO crowd is simply the conservative reasoning crowd, not necessarily the unscientific one. Why? Well, nutrition science still advocates for low-fat, low-sodium, low-cholesterol diets. Doctors still prescribe Lipitor; Tylenol is still OTC; prostate cancer is still "cured" with unnecessary invasive surgeries, mammograms although questioned as a self-fulfilling prophecy are still widely used, CAT scans with their huge amounts of radiation are still performed for benign symptoms, and so on. Just because there's a (poor!) study about something, it's not a good enough reason for people to change their reasoning - so the heuristic is that everything new is too risky for the slightly better yield. I might be pro-science and pro-technology, but when it comes to what I ingest and how I live, I'm more than conservative, and it's been working well for me. Most science is bad science, unfortunately. Until AI starts dominating science, I can't trust scientists 100%, sorry! Especially about super complex stuff like nutrition and metabolism! Our bodies are the most complex system in the visible universe, and I don't think we can predict the outcomes of each intervention. What we know for a fact is that we're best adapted to our tradition diets and foods!
Re:GMO safety debate is over
by nikolay on Wednesday May 25, 2016 @08:18AM
(#11769217)
By "bad science" I meant bad health science and I apologize for not being clear. That also happens to be the department of science most obviously linked to commercial interest! A lot of studies have sponsored outcomes!
"Traditional" varies from population to population and that's a subject for Epigenetics and the fact that it takes 4-6 generations to fully adapt to a new diet.
Re:GMO safety debate is over
by mhkool on Tuesday May 24, 2016 @07:05AM
(#11760473)
The article has a link to "the report" but is merely a link to the website of "The Natanional Academies of SCIENCES, ENGINEERING and MEDICINE". The actual report is not public: you must pay USD 71.
The "Who are we" button on the website is vague: Each report is produced by a committee of experts selected by the Academies to address a particular statement of task.
I want to be able to verify if this report is made by independant individuals, but cannot.
Mark Lymas, the author, does not say anything about the content of the report... nothing is said about evidence. This article is not worth reading.
Re:GMO safety debate is over
by touristtam on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:07AM
(#11791869)
patenting the "living" and turning it into a product. Like sterile seeds making it impossible to reuse part of your own production to saw the next season.
Re:GMO safety debate is over
by DanBC on Saturday May 28, 2016 @11:10AM
(#11791883)
To be fair the corps are damned if they do and damned if they don't.
If they release seed that grows fertile seed they get accused of releasing GMO into the environment.
If they include "terminator"[1] genes to they get accused of making it impossible to reuse your own seed. Even though many conventionally bred hybrid seeds are the same.
[1] that's a terrible name for the technology. What were they thinking?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutagenesis
One could also argue that directed mutation GMOs are safer. Because unlike random mutations, on purpose mutations are thoroughly checked afterwards.
And mutations that are random but rapidly through modern non-"GMO" breeding techniques are no more proven by thousands of years than GMOs are, and those developing and deploying them have a lot less knowledge of what changes are induced and what health impacts they may have.
But since they aren't GMOs their apparently okay with the anti-GMO crowd. There is no rational or scientific reason for this.
> Most science is bad science, unfortunately. Until AI starts dominating science, I can't trust scientists 100%, sorry!
Yes, let's distrust Gravity Laws, don't trust physicists
> What we know for a fact is that we're best adapted to our tradition diets and foods!
What are those tradition diets and foods?
"Traditional" varies from population to population and that's a subject for Epigenetics and the fact that it takes 4-6 generations to fully adapt to a new diet.
So, no, conservative reasoning is not an adequate explanation of the anti-GMO crowd.
I want to be able to verify if this report is made by independant individuals, but cannot.
Mark Lymas, the author, does not say anything about the content of the report... nothing is said about evidence. This article is not worth reading.
BBC: "Royal Society calls for review of European GM ban"
http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-36359682
Royal Society: "Genetically modified (GM) plants: questions and answers"
https://royalsociety.org/topics-policy/projects/gm-plants/
I thought the "issue" wasn't solely based around human food consumption ...
If they release seed that grows fertile seed they get accused of releasing GMO into the environment.
If they include "terminator"[1] genes to they get accused of making it impossible to reuse your own seed. Even though many conventionally bred hybrid seeds are the same.
[1] that's a terrible name for the technology. What were they thinking?