By the way, I'm from Chicago, and knew many talented folks with 2-3 years post college getting in the $70k's. Much lower than the easy $100k quoted here.
Software that is really slow to release and change due to its customers being slow and bureaucratic have less business need to hire the top tier developers that can keep them competitive - their primary levers in driving business are now sales based, and if you want a career in sales I think those companies are excellent. When HP acquired the company I worked for, they compared themselves in compensation and growth to IBM, SAP, etc. - no mention of Google, Microsoft, or even Yahoo. Furthermore, software developers in the US have so many options that can result in lots of churn when they get assigned really terrible technical work while there's fewer options or a different management approach that treats human labor as a commodity (competes primarily upon price, not much else - it is inefficient to have John Carmack write a bunch of REST calls for a CRUD app, but maybe a team of 12 very cheap developers that are poorly managed can be thrown into a basement and figure it out). It's just globalization at work.
American living standards are high (and should well be as the world's largest, richest economy) IMO and salaries are adjusted for the socioeconomic expectations. I grew up here as a child of immigrants and a father used to being abused as an employee relatively (in the bottom 30% of compensation for experience and skill). The kind of luxuries that people expect all the time in terms of housing and leisure activities is a bit myopic though even among Americans that grew up in poverty decades ago I've noticed. "Country people" driving Mercedes SUVs and living in 2500 sq ft houses that need maids is evidently something that exists.
I lived perfectly fine by my ideas of adequate living for years after college on less than $1k / mo because I didn't have many interests that required much money but this is around the poverty line it seems. I'd love to live with such a simple life and bank the rest of my income but it'd be a lonely road.
If you're working in the city with a wide range of ages, you have people who are more 'settled' living out in the suburbs and commuting in.
But if you're working in, say, Alpharetta, with mostly young people, a lot may have moved to be close to work (or if they're fresh out of college, taken an apartment near by anyway).
Because, yeah, everywhere I've worked in Atlanta, a majority of people have had some pretty lousy commutes.
Not to mention the 60% savings in cost of living over SV. http://www.bestplaces.net/cost-of-living/san-francisco-ca/at...
And, at the end of the day housing is so cost effective it is almost not crazy to move for a job, even within the metro.
Despite the dollar utility value difference I'll still assert that the most optimal career path for ambitious, diligent tech workers regardless of whether you're looking for money or for long term life balance is to go for as high as you can comfortably go in the Bay Area or maybe NY when young and with few expenses and go somewhere lower cost of living to settle down. Finance people aren't being stupid by going to NYC early in their career I'd imagine. This career pattern is supported by a study linked on HN a while ago (sorry, can't find link at the moment) with a report on expected earnings when going from the Bay Area elsewhere - starting with as high of salary as possible helps negotiate your pay when going to a lower cost of living area. Your marketable skills should have grown better working at a tech company doing cutting edge projects than for the usual enterprise shovelware projects that are the bread and butter of tech companies outside tech hubs as well.
Unlike the FB or Googler comparisons often cited I'm nobody special or talented and managed to get $130k+ from miserly employers in not very tech friendly areas, so I can't see how anyone with decent talent taking local jobs in places with as horrible traffic like Chicago or Atlanta with solid career prospects would want to go there. Lack of locally grown talent from universities certainly isn't a problem for most (Georgia Tech is pretty solid, for example). So doesn't that mean they're suffering from brain drain to a fair degree?