Yeah, there seem to be very definitive statements in these comments without a basic understanding of the recording process. I wonder if these are the same people who swear they can tell the difference between various playback formats or when they use gold XLR cables.
Re:The Dark Art of Mastering Music
by Sephiroth87 on Monday May 23, 2016 @09:46AM
(#11753782)
Apart from the misunderstanding, I think it would be actually interesting if you could buy the un-mastered version, plus "mastering" files to use depending on your setup (e.g.: crappy headphones, car stereo, home stereo), but that would require multiple mastering sessions and wouldn't probably be very cost effective...
Or you could crowd-source them but then it might go against the creators intentions...
Re:The Dark Art of Mastering Music
by BugsBunnySan on Monday May 23, 2016 @10:07AM
(#11753921)
In a different field (digital cinema) the above is being done for color, lookup the ACES colorspace and workflows...
(Very) Basically the camera's recording goes through a process to make it into a standardized ACES colorspace. It will then being processed by editing, VFX, grading, etc... and then there's output transforms from ACES for each output device, like a cinema projector, a home TV or a mobile phone.
And yes, AFAIR, that does need grading for each targeted output device, because of how we see and perceive color depending on the environment we're in...
It would be awesome (EDIT: to have something like that) for music as well
If you want the actual stems of the song, that would actually be the music in it's pre-mixed form. It wouldn't even be mixed at that point, let alone mastered.