News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by shaqbert on Monday May 23, 2016 @05:39AM (#11752780)
This is not really about micro reactors, but about making the monolith power plant more like a microservice modular thing. So that you can potentially prevent decomissioning after 40 to 60 years and keep it operating much longer.

The downside of nuclear power still remains though: - still high upfront costs (maybe lower that monolith plants, but still freaking high) - poisonous and radioactive fission products that are hard to deal with - perverse incentives between economic efficiency and safety (did I mention that a couple of those babies [1] here would have prevented the fukushima disaster)

[1]: http://us.areva.com/EN/home-1495/new-challenges-proven-solut...

Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by Aelinsaar on Monday May 23, 2016 @09:47AM (#11753793)
To be fair, the byproducts are not something we're unaware of how to manage, we're just socially and politically unwilling to do it. Likewise, we know how to design and maintain much safer and more efficient reactors than anything we currently have running, but we lack the social and political will to make the change.

Besides, we like to pretend that burning coal isn't killing millions of us around the world, decade in, decade out. Focusing on the real human cost of when nuclear goes wrong, vs. when coal goes right makes it an easy choice.

Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by jon_richards on Monday May 23, 2016 @10:14AM (#11753965)
Per kilowatt, nuclear energy is by far the safest. People fall off wind and solar installations all the time. Hydro fails catastrophically.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by Aelinsaar on Monday May 23, 2016 @10:32AM (#11754078)
I don't know about Solar and wind being inherently less safe, in fact I'd disagree with that. The issue though, is that we still can't rely on them to power our entire grid. Hydro though, even without failure, seems to have a pretty undesirable environmental impact. Nuclear has to go catastrophically wrong for that to be the case.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by bewaretheirs on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:35PM (#11755399)
For residential installs, solar systems go up on roofs, a few kilowatts at a time. The main risk is to the installers (they fall off). Little capacity per roof, every roof different, every fall a potential hazard = higher risk per kilowatt than you might think..
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by mschuster91 on Monday May 23, 2016 @02:24PM (#11755775)
> The main risk is to the installers (they fall off).

Huge NO. The biggest risk is for firefighters if any part of the PV panel or the technology or the roof itself catch fire!

The DC side can easily pack in a couple hundred volts DC with double-digit amperages. And you can't turn it off unless the sun goes dark... not to mention that it's hard for firefighters to fight a fire if the whole roof is PV-panel-filled and something in the roof is burning.

Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by Aelinsaar on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:49PM (#11755504)
I suppose so, but it's a risk that can be managed with existing technology, and without spending insane amounts of money.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by howlin on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:27PM (#11755338)
> Hydro though, even without failure, seems to have a pretty undesirable environmental impact. Nuclear has to go catastrophically wrong for that to be the case.

Arguably, the Chernobyl disaster was an environmental boon by forcing humans out of a region and creating a de facto nature preserve.

Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by noobermin on Monday May 23, 2016 @03:07PM (#11756055)
And people don't fall off nuclear installations as well? Death is tragic in all cases, but are death rates of workers in installations worse for solar installations? I can see it in wind installations, but are accidental rates in solar installations worse than those in the installation of nuclear plants?
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by Aelinsaar on Monday May 23, 2016 @05:52PM (#11757347)
Or radio masts, cell towers, smokestacks, etc. It's a known risk of working up on a tall structure, but it's also a risk that's understood, and managed with safety equipment and best practices. We don't seem to compose a dirge for every tree that gets trimmed around a utility pole either.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by stcredzero on Monday May 23, 2016 @02:23PM (#11755765)
People fall off wind and solar installations all the time.

But our society has always just shrugged its shoulders at this cost, so long as its paid by the working class. (In Texas, it's the lowest very rungs of the working class that get sent up radio towers.) It's different when the damage directly impacts homes, particularly those of white collar workers.

Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by ptaipale on Monday May 23, 2016 @02:47PM (#11755915)
Sounds a bit like a chip on the shoulder when, in this context, you talk about radio towers, which aren't windmills or solar plants (although yes, accidents happen also there).
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by stcredzero on Monday May 23, 2016 @06:40PM (#11757605)
Also applies to coal miners. There are still a lot of fairly hazardous jobs in our society that our society isn't all that concerned about the workers being fully covered/compensated.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by mkesper on Monday May 23, 2016 @10:25AM (#11754022)
How can you say that without being cynic when it made big parts of Japan uninhabitable for centuries if not thousands of years?
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by JorgeGT on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:09AM (#11754334)
The failure of the Banqiao Dam in China in 1975 killed 171,000 people; 11,000,000 people lost their homes. This is many orders of magnitude higher than the casualties and damages directly attributed to the failure of Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant.

Furthermore, Fukushima Daiichi was an old design (more than a decade older than Chernobyl nº4 reactor) whereas modern designs are much more safe.

Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by Aelinsaar on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:15AM (#11754384)
Fukushima Daiichi was also subjected to a historically significant natural disaster, it wasn't exactly an "everyday" or even "every century" event.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by guscost on Monday May 23, 2016 @12:35PM (#11754924)
And the area around the reactor isn't uninhabitable, it's just illegal to live there at the moment.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by ptaipale on Monday May 23, 2016 @02:49PM (#11755933)
Yes. What is funny is that some of my countrymen, who lived in Japan as expats, left the area because of radiation, and came back home, where the natural background radiation is higher than in the evacuated Fukushima area.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by makomk on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:00PM (#11755115)
From what I can tell, Banqiao Dam was dual-purpose: it was intended for flood control as well as power generation. If China had sourced power from a nuclear plant, the dam would likely still have failed and killed hundreds of thousands of people, we just wouldn't be able to attribute those deaths to hydroelectric power.

Furthermore, modern nuclear power plants may be safe but they aren't exactly economically viable, which is why nuclear operators are so keen on extending the operation of existing plants of the same design as Fukushima Daiichi. Also, I'm pretty sure the official position on Fukushima was that it was safe, right up until it wasn't.

Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by JorgeGT on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:37PM (#11755409)
The fact remains that hydro power requires storing the potential energy of a very large amount of water. This is inherently a danger for the population living downstream. I certainly would prefer to live in the vicinity of a nuclear power plant rather than in the floodpath of a large dam.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by Aelinsaar on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:50PM (#11755515)
Not to mention that if something goes wrong with a plant, you'll probably have time to evacuate. If a dam fails catastrophically, you'll probably first know when you feel the ground shaking, and that will be too late for you.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by theamk on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:00AM (#11754264)
Do you have quantitative information about that? I was always wondering how big is Fukushima's nuclear incident zone (in km^2) today. How much bigger is it compared to coal waste ponds / landfills, or hydroelectric dam which provides the same amount of power?
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by Aelinsaar on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:17AM (#11754396)
The problem with coal as well, is that the effect of its pollution is known to contribute to many deaths a year, especially in the elderly, people with compromised cardiopulmonary systems, and of course, the asthmatic. It's not like a nuclear disaster though, where someone comes in "radioactive" with coal. The best we can do is explain the statistical link.

When nuclear goes wrong, it's much less lethal, but so much more easy to recognize and very dramatic. Then again, we live in a world of people obsessed with shark attacks and winning the lottery, but who drive around in cars all day.

Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by joelwilliamson on Monday May 23, 2016 @12:55PM (#11755060)
The exclusion zone is 20km, so the area will be around 600 km^2. Compare that to Lake Mead, which is 640 km^2 and runs a power station with half the installed capacity of Fukushima Daiichi.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by vilhelm_s on Monday May 23, 2016 @02:02PM (#11755602)
A circle of 20km is 1200 km^2.

In this case, only half the circle was over land, but the evacuation zone also extended about 40km downwind, based on the amount of radiation, so the original exclusion zone was also about 1200 km^2.

Since then, part of the exclusion has been lifted: I think in this map, the green areas are places which are no longer restricted. The yellow areas can be visited with a permit, but you are not allowed to live in them or stay over night. The pink area is the "difficult to return" zone, I think the government treats this as a total loss and reimburses house owners for the full value of their property.

http://userdisk.webry.biglobe.ne.jp/001/285/53/N000/000/009/...

From counting pixels in the picture, it seems the yellow+pink area is 670 km^2, and the pink area is 330 km^2.

Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by Shivetya on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:41AM (#11754554)
So what is holding back the safer/efficient reactors? Certification funding or proof of concept that leads to industry acceptance and federal funding?
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by Aelinsaar on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:50AM (#11754620)
Mostly politics. At every level, there is resistance, and motivation for politicians in congress (especially senators) to take a strong pro-coal, NIBMY to Nuclear stance. Any senator who accepts a disposal site, or new reactor site in their state is putting their career in the line. The kind of people who do that, tend not to become or stay senators.

The end result is that we're just sitting it out, because we've made it prohibitively expensive (in terms of licensing, and in terms of political capital).

Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by damptowel on Monday May 23, 2016 @06:50PM (#11757656)
Popular support. Legacy of Cold War era anti nuke propaganda and ridiculous portrayal of reactors and nuclear waste in fiction have lead to a skewed public perception on which politicians don't want to get burnt. Fukushima happened. Paperwork gets expensive. Active failsafe systems several layers deep complicate construction of plants. All of this loops back onto corporations and public institutions not wanting to invest into research.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by mikeash on Monday May 23, 2016 @10:33AM (#11754080)
No need for fancy chemical whatsis, all Fukushima needed to avoid disaster was a taller wall, or for the generators to be placed on the roof instead of in the basement.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by bischofs on Monday May 23, 2016 @09:53AM (#11753827)
I think nuclear is a technology that is beyond what the current human society can support - we really are not ready for the technology until we deal with uneducated masses, fundamentalism, techno-literacy etc
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by jerf on Monday May 23, 2016 @10:24AM (#11754011)
"The masses are too uneducated for nuclear" would be a lot more compelling an argument if those who are putatively "the educated" weren't quite against it too. It's not poor uneducated people filing lawsuits against every nuclear reactor every step of the way, and unless you mean "environmental fundamentalist" (which isn't out of the question) it's not any other sort of fundamentalist I can think of either.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by TeMPOraL on Monday May 23, 2016 @12:16PM (#11754798)
Some people play the game of life cooperatively, by trying to help each other and make the world a better place for everyone. But there's also lot of those who play it competitively - who don't mind abusing the system and fucking everyone else over as long as they get what they want for themselves and those close to them. You can see plenty of the latter type among many educated people "filling lawsuits against every nuclear reactor every step of the way", along with many other things. The problem isn't with those on the other side of the issue who are honestly opposing it; the problem is with people on both sides who don't care about subject matter at all, but only about how to profit from it.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by guscost on Monday May 23, 2016 @12:53PM (#11755054)
In my experience American society is organized around the belief that people can be left to pursue their own goals without everything falling apart. While there will still be corruption and selfishness, the government and culture work together to make sure this problem is, if not much less serious than in other kinds of societies, at least not more serious either.

It sounds like you are saying this isn't good enough, and that you would be against any powerful new technology until we can fix these problems. Until the fabled Eschaton/Utopia/perfect society arrives, basically.

I think this is a terribly misguided attitude. Cheap and plentiful power will save and help a lot more people than those hurt by accidents. Especially taking into account the amazing safety science and engineering that goes into this particular technology, and its amazing safety record apart from Chernobyl (you know, that graphite-moderated reactor with no concept of passive safety).

Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by TeMPOraL on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:05PM (#11755150)
You misunderstood me; maybe my comment wasn't written clearly enough. Personally, I'm very much pro-nuclear for very much the reasons you articulated. I definitely don't think we need to stop good ideas because of social problems. I merely wanted to point them out - that nuclear energy (and many other things as well) is being blocked not because some people are wrong, but because some people don't care about it at all, but use it as a way to make a profit.
Re:Small Modular Nuclear Reactors Overcome Existing Barriers... by guscost on Monday May 23, 2016 @01:21PM (#11755275)
OK it seems like I had your point pretty much backwards, whoops.