Re:IBM is not doing "cognitive computing" with Watson
by comex on Monday May 23, 2016 @03:57AM
(#11752502)
For what it's worth, I tried the translation demo[1] on some Wikipedia text in Italian and French, along with Google Translate on the same text, and Watson seemed nearly on par but consistently slightly worse. (I also tried Bing, which seemed more even with Google.) I guess this is to be expected, given the relative lack of importance to IBM, but I was vaguely hoping that Watson could somehow afford to spend more CPU time on it or something (after all, their main business is selling access; Google and Bing also do that but mainly exist as a free tool for consumers) and get a better result. Oh well.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:IBM is not doing "cognitive computing" with Watson
by Bartweiss on Monday May 23, 2016 @10:51AM
(#11754198)
I think this may boil down to dedicated intelligence. Google Translate is an entire project devoted solely to efficient, human-useful text translation, where Watson is a more general-purpose language processor. Certainly Watson must have dedicated translation logic, but I would be surprised if there are any narrow domains where Watson beats strong single-purpose competitors.
Re:IBM is not doing "cognitive computing" with Watson
by pesenti on Monday May 23, 2016 @11:00AM
(#11754269)
We do have a team dedicated to Machine Translation (the same team that actually introduced the statistical approach - the "IBM Models" - in the 90s) but that team had been focused more on non-European languages. If you search the literature you will find that the IBM team is leading for languages like Arabic and Chinese but trailing for European language. We are working on that.
Re:IBM is not doing "cognitive computing" with Watson
by Bartweiss on Monday May 23, 2016 @12:07PM
(#11754741)
This is a really interesting response, thank you (and thanks for answering so many questions in this thread).
That result makes a lot of sense - Google has been working with the huge corpus of English-European translations (e.g. UN reports) and getting impressive results largely because there's so much data available with such direct equivalences.
Just based on personal experimentation, they're much less capable with longer "translation distances" like phonogram<-->logogram and Indo-European<-->Sino-Tibetan. I didn't know IBM was leading on those long-distance translations, that's cool to hear.