Re:Achieving a Perfect SSL Labs Score with Go
by hodgesrm on Sunday May 22, 2016 @02:48PM
(#11749722)
Perhaps not but it is astonishing to me that many (most?) of the comparisons between Go and Java omit security. In particular, it's hard see how you can assert Go (or any language for that matter) is well-suited for distributed computing without considering issues like authentication and encryption.
Here are a couple of examples of what I mean. [2] cites use of Go in financial apps without a single mention of security.
[1] http://thenewstack.io/a-closer-look-at-golang-from-an-archit...
[2] http://www.techworld.com/apps/why-googles-go-programming-lan...
Re:Achieving a Perfect SSL Labs Score with Go
by tptacek on Sunday May 22, 2016 @04:18PM
(#11750095)
I don't understand this argument. I'm a security practitioner and, in particular, a software security expert. I don't think either language is intrinsically more or less secure. But Go does have a better TLS stack.
Re:Achieving a Perfect SSL Labs Score with Go
by hodgesrm on Sunday May 22, 2016 @07:53PM
(#11750847)
Building secure systems in Java requires a lot of arcane knowledge due to the complexity of the libraries. For instance, you can't just throw a switch and convert all socket-based communication to TLS. I'm not arguing that Go is necessarily better but it's a useful consideration in language evaluation.
But maybe I'm missing your point.
Re:Achieving a Perfect SSL Labs Score with Go
by meddlepal on Sunday May 22, 2016 @01:50PM
(#11749518)
In Java's defense its TLS stack and frameworks using it have grown organically over 20 years. Let's see how Go is doing with consistency in 2030.
Re:Achieving a Perfect SSL Labs Score with Go
by tptacek on Sunday May 22, 2016 @01:59PM
(#11749540)
It's not time that makes Java's TLS stack bad; it's that the TLS stacks are afterthoughts. Java could be competitive with Go if it attracted someone of Langley's caliber to manage a coherent, designed-for-security TLS stack, and then the ecosystem was managed to ensure that everyone used that stack.
It's not a fair comparison: Go has a TLS stack that is shepherded by Adam Langley, who is one of the Internet's foremost experts on TLS.