Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars
by venomsnake on Saturday May 21, 2016 @05:50PM
(#11746339)
Engineering solved morality once again.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
try {
enforceTopSpeed(getMaxSpeed(clear_road_ahead));
}
catch (CatastrophicBrakeFailureException ex) {
// ???
}Sudden brake failure on a properly maintained car is vanishingly unlikely. Having it occur the instant you need to slam the brakes for a life-or-death intervention will basically never happen.
For the vast, vast majority of catastrophic failures, the basic procedure of pulling over and stopping the car will be absolutely fine.
This is probably the perfect example of why I find these discussions massive wastes of time.
If there is a catastrophic brake failure currently, with human drivers, it isn't seen as a deep philosophical issue. I have absolutely no clue why this changes because the car is operated differently.
Re:The Amorality of Self-Driving Cars
by venomsnake on Sunday May 22, 2016 @03:13AM
(#11747641)
turnOffEngine();
The engine turned off can be used very effectively as a brake.
Better catch EngineControlException. Oh, and TireShotBySniperException. Brake failure is just an example. There dozens of sensors and subsystems with innumerable combinations that can fail and put the vehicle in a state where some kind of collision is unavoidable. It will have to decide what to do.
Humans end up calling randomPanic() at some point, so maybe that's what the vehicle should do to avoid accusations that it "intentionally" harmed one party or another.