Re:Standard deviation is ready for retirement: Nassim Taleb ...
by closed on Saturday May 21, 2016 @10:51AM
(#11744850)
Yes, that is wrong. It sounds like you might be thinking about the standard deviation of normally distributed data. In this case, you can say something like, "the probability an observation will be within about [mean-2sd, mean+2sd] is 95%".
But that's assuming the distribution is normal. In other cases, this doesn't hold, but there are more general statements, like Chebyshev's inequality.
Chebyshev's inequality: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chebyshev%27s_inequality
EDIT:
I have no idea when people would describe SD as MAD, but wouldn't be too surprised, since people first coming into statistics often seem to have trouble conceptualizing how a squared difference could be viewed. It would be surprising if a trained statistician mixed the two up, because SD and MAD arise from something they should be familiar with--Lebesgue spaces.
Re:Standard deviation is ready for retirement: Nassim Taleb ...
by juped on Sunday May 22, 2016 @04:21AM
(#11747775)
I've got a very non-statistics math background, but what you say suggests that there would be a nice way to visualize standard deviations two-dimensionally (since they arise from an L_2 norm), and that it's the one-dimensional "bell curve cross-section width" pictures that confuse people.
If not, can you give me an example of the typical description people give for STD that actually describes MAD?