Re:Tech firms may violate Palo Alto zoning: Writing code not...
by dragonwriter on Friday May 20, 2016 @07:42PM
(#11742397)
> In the United States, source code is protected as free speech.
That's unclear in the general sense. There have been some Circuit Court decisions that held something like that in at least some circumstances, and some criticism that the broader of those are in some tension with applicable Supreme Court precedent. AFAIK, the Supreme Court has never held that source code is speech in the broad sense.
> Limitations on free speech are subject to "strict scrutiny"
Incorrect. Content-based limitations on speech are subject to strict scrutiny, content-neutral limitations on speech are subject to intermediate scrutiny. Restriction of a particular medium of speech without regard to content would seem to be a content-neutral restriction.
That's unclear in the general sense. There have been some Circuit Court decisions that held something like that in at least some circumstances, and some criticism that the broader of those are in some tension with applicable Supreme Court precedent. AFAIK, the Supreme Court has never held that source code is speech in the broad sense.
> Limitations on free speech are subject to "strict scrutiny"
Incorrect. Content-based limitations on speech are subject to strict scrutiny, content-neutral limitations on speech are subject to intermediate scrutiny. Restriction of a particular medium of speech without regard to content would seem to be a content-neutral restriction.