News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Turbulent times for Formula 1 engines result in unprecede... by aidenn0 on Friday May 20, 2016 @06:07PM (#11741901)
Any mention of the Prius using the Atkinson cycle brings out the inner pedant in me. I suppose to a certain degree, Toyota makes the engine, so they can call it what they want, but late intake valve closing is clearly quite distinct from the engine Atkinson invented (and indeed that design might not have achieved one goal of Atkinson's engine which was to circumvent the Otto cycle patent).

Indeed, if there were any existing cycle for which it would make sense to name the Prius' engine after, it would be the Miller cycle, though that has always meant some sort of external compression of intake air (the original patent used a turbo, but all Miller cycle engine's I've ever seen have superchargers).

One other interesting note is that the Miller cycle works best with a supercharger due to increased relative boost at low RPMs, where the drop in torque due to the late intake valve closing hurts the most. The Prius nicely sidesteps this by using an electric motor at low speeds.

Re:Turbulent times for Formula 1 engines result in unprecede... by nradov on Friday May 20, 2016 @08:37PM (#11742578)
I recently ran across an interesting article about how Mazda has built two cars with Miller cycle engines. Only one was supercharged.

http://jalopnik.com/5959547/forgotten-cars-the-mazda-milleni...

Re:Turbulent times for Formula 1 engines result in unprecede... by aidenn0 on Saturday May 21, 2016 @01:20AM (#11743329)
Okay the Mazda 1.3L NA Miller cycle in the 2 is essentially the same cycle as the Prius. It probably won't have the best acceleration in the world, particularly at low RPMs.

When the Prius came out, I remember several people saying you couldn't call it a Miller cycle due to it being NA. (Actually a few people said it needed a positive-displacement supercharger, until it was pointed out that the original Miller cycle patent was paired with a turbocharger).

Re:Turbulent times for Formula 1 engines result in unprecede... by mrfusion on Friday May 20, 2016 @06:28PM (#11742025)
I'm not understanding the Atkinson cycle. It seems like less compression would be worse. What am I missing?
Re:Turbulent times for Formula 1 engines result in unprecede... by Gravityloss on Friday May 20, 2016 @07:34PM (#11742362)
There are limits to compression. The fuel-air mix will combust spontaneously if you compress it too much.

So that's why max compression ratio is something like ten. So a normal engine has compression of ten and expansion of ten.

A more efficient engine with a different cycle might still have compression of ten but expansion goes up to say eleven. This means it's possible to extract more power at the end of the power stroke.

There are some tricks to achieve that. Toyota does it by creating an engine with a geometry that would otherwise have very high compression and expansion ratio, but they can avoid the high compression ratio: they don't close the intake valves when the cylinder has been sucked in full of fresh air, like in a normal engine. They keep them open so at the start of the compression cycle, fresh air flows backwards out of the cylinder for a while, before they close the valves.

Re:Turbulent times for Formula 1 engines result in unprecede... by ThenAsNow on Friday May 20, 2016 @10:26PM (#11742890)
Actually, the advantage of the Atkinson or Miller cycles is not due to avoiding autoignition limits. Rather it is because of, as you pointed out, the greater than unity ratio of (expansion ratio)/(compression ratio). So you are improving the ratio of work that can be extracted from the power cycle as compared to the work that you are doing on the mixture.

For the same engine displacement as a standard Otto cycle engine, the maximum power you can develop with the Atkinson-type cycle is decreased, hence you trade efficiency for power density. The Miller cycle approach is a way to shift that balance back toward the Otto range by doing some precompression on the air.

Re:Turbulent times for Formula 1 engines result in unprecede... by aidenn0 on Saturday May 21, 2016 @01:16AM (#11743319)
Actually the compression stroke can only lose you energy. It's the power stroke that you want to be as long as possible for maximum efficiency.

On top of this, there is an upper bound to the compression ratio for a given fuel-air mixture due to auto-ignition (basically if you compress a fuel-air mixture enough, it will ignite on its own).

So by having the compression stroke shorter than the power stroke, you can harvest more energy at a given compression ratio.