Re:Are You Successful? If So, You've Already Won the Lottery
by coldtea on Friday May 20, 2016 @05:02PM
(#11741489)
How is it "wrong, wrong, wrong"? The article gave many examples, several of them from actual studies and statistics.
You merely labelled the whole thing as "excuses" in an argument-free comment.
>At some point we'll exhaust all excuses for success in life other than grit, dedication, and plain old hard work. Chance is just another one down the line.
I can fathom how some people really believe they did more "grit, dedication and plain old hard work" than hundreds of millions of other working-to-the-bone poor that never get nowhere, from poor African Americans to third world sweatshop workers...
I can only excuse this mentality in "rags to riches" people, because, even though they are clearly outliers, their life's story and survivorship bias makes them to overlook the whole issue, and turn it into: "hey, If I've made it out from poverty into millionaire, everyone can, it just takes hard work", while forgetting the non-work-dependent chances they got that others didn't.
But they also forget the more important part: that what's important is not whether "everyone can do it" (period) but whether "everyone can do it with EQUAL effort".
If a poor black person has to put 3x the effort to make it compared to a white guy who just had it easy because of rich parents, college funds, encouragement, etc -- then sure, it's not IMPOSSIBLE to do it. But it's hardly FAIR (level starting point), and it's far harder and thus rarer (plus, if it takes 3x the effort it might not even mean we'll have only 3 times less poor black successful persons as percentage. It might even get it to 1/10 or 1/20, because the breaking point that makes you fail or give up might not scale linearly with effort).
You merely labelled the whole thing as "excuses" in an argument-free comment.
>At some point we'll exhaust all excuses for success in life other than grit, dedication, and plain old hard work. Chance is just another one down the line.
I can fathom how some people really believe they did more "grit, dedication and plain old hard work" than hundreds of millions of other working-to-the-bone poor that never get nowhere, from poor African Americans to third world sweatshop workers...
Inevitable link:
http://thewireless.co.nz/articles/the-pencilsword-on-a-plate
I can only excuse this mentality in "rags to riches" people, because, even though they are clearly outliers, their life's story and survivorship bias makes them to overlook the whole issue, and turn it into: "hey, If I've made it out from poverty into millionaire, everyone can, it just takes hard work", while forgetting the non-work-dependent chances they got that others didn't.
But they also forget the more important part: that what's important is not whether "everyone can do it" (period) but whether "everyone can do it with EQUAL effort".
If a poor black person has to put 3x the effort to make it compared to a white guy who just had it easy because of rich parents, college funds, encouragement, etc -- then sure, it's not IMPOSSIBLE to do it. But it's hardly FAIR (level starting point), and it's far harder and thus rarer (plus, if it takes 3x the effort it might not even mean we'll have only 3 times less poor black successful persons as percentage. It might even get it to 1/10 or 1/20, because the breaking point that makes you fail or give up might not scale linearly with effort).