Re:Standard deviation is ready for retirement: Nassim Taleb ...
by CamperBob2 on Friday May 20, 2016 @04:19PM
(#11741141)
It's really pointless to argue about the "best" deviation algorithm, at least on the basis of how it responds to outliers. The process of identifying and ignoring/deprecating outliers isn't something that can or should be lumped in with a simple notion of deviation, be it RMS, MAD, SD, or whatever. Any simple algorithm that you come up with to represent one data set may fail badly with another for this reason (and others.)
Outliers need to be removed, or at least understood, before performing any statistical calculations.
Outliers need to be removed, or at least understood, before performing any statistical calculations.