Re:Standard deviation is ready for retirement: Nassim Taleb ...
by Tloewald on Friday May 20, 2016 @12:03PM
(#11738929)
That's as clear as mud. What does a -20 vs. a 20 mean? That it was colder at noon than at midnight?
Assuming that there was some sensible definition (e.g. deviation from the past mean temperature, which is not at all what was stated) then "average deviation" has two obvious interpretations. Re-labeling "standard deviation" or "mean deviation" would not be helpful in this case, and the -20 and 20 values STILL don't help the case.
Re:Standard deviation is ready for retirement: Nassim Taleb ...
by enugu on Friday May 20, 2016 @12:53PM
(#11739398)
The article isn't clear but the deviation is either from the sample mean or the mean of the underlying random variable. You are trying to find the expected difference from the average and hence the absolute value(otherwise, the positive and negative deviations cancel out).
Yes, it would be silly to convert a -20 to 20 if the mean isn't 0.
The advantage with STD is that it is easier to compute relative to MAD in a situation like a random walk. For instance when one has a +1, -1 equal probability one dimensional random walk, so the mean is 0, X = sum of X_i, E(X²) = n is straightforward, whereas computing E(|X|) is not so easy.