News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by thephyber on Thursday May 19, 2016 @05:12AM (#11728939)
I still don't understand this argument. Yes, it matters that residents use less water than prior to the drought -- at least a lot more than you give it credit.

The residential water reservoir system in California isn't being plundered by Big Agri, Big Ranch, Big Bottled Water, or Big Frack. Yes, those things use most of the water in the state. No, the vast majority of that water would not otherwise make it into an existing reservoir that supplies residents. It would make it into a non-reservoir body of water or it would help replenish the water table (which is what they were using until this winter).

There is a finite volume of reservoir space and it currently takes several years to build new ones. There is a fixed and finite amount of surface area upstream of those reservoirs that collect and consolidate rainwater into the reservoirs. Average long-term usage by a slightly growing population (at least until recently) is still outpacing long-term replenishment rates of those reservoirs.

Yes, when California urban residents get fined for running their sprinklers mid-day, it helps align incentives. Yes, incentivizing residents to buy low-flow toilets helps (at least when they don't clog due to insufficient force to flush solids).

I'd rather we kick golf courses and sprawling estates off of the residential water system or at least charge incrementally more for more water used per property. But it still doesn't change the fact that the vast majority of water rights in the state is (1) used by industry that doesn't get their water from the same reservoirs that residences do and (2) the current water rights regime is enshrined in the California constitution so it would take a well organized campaign and a tremendous amount of political willpower to get it changed. I don't see that happening right now, especially since it threatens several major industries in the state.

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by joshuaheard on Thursday May 19, 2016 @10:49AM (#11730646)
It's quite simple. Residential water use is 10% of total state water usage, while Agriculture uses 90%. So, if you save 25% of Residential water, you save 2.5% overall, but if you save 25% of Agricultural water usage, you save 27.5% overall. So, common sense dictates you seek savings in the Agricultural space.

This is especially true where the Agricultural space does not use efficient free market principals to allocate resources, but uses an antiquated, arbitrary, and subsidized bureaucratic system that should be reformed but for powerful lobbying interests.

Your description of water distribution is not accurate. Water in Southern California, whether for Residential use or Agriculture, is mostly brought down from Northern California via the Colorado River and several man-made aqueducts. Since the water is distributed not based on any rational manner, we have Agriculture using water to grow rice in the desert. I won't even discuss the wacky environmental laws that prevent water from going to grow food because of some tiny fish somewhere.

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by rconti on Thursday May 19, 2016 @12:40PM (#11731473)
Brought down from Northern California via the Colorado River, huh? Might want to check a map. Or, like, the name of the river.

http://media.web.britannica.com/eb-media/60/89860-004-F57B19...

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by joshuaheard on Thursday May 19, 2016 @03:01PM (#11732781)
True, I should have said brought down from Northern California and the Colorado River.

https://cnx.org/resources/226094ef8ecea226912aec367cf3fbe445...

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by jedberg on Thursday May 19, 2016 @01:15PM (#11731766)
It's not that simple though. If you reduce residential use by 25%, there is no impact to the economy -- actually there is a boost because of the increased revenues for landscapers and home improvement stores.

On the other hand, if you reduce agriculture by even 10%, it would destroy our state's economy.

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by yarou on Thursday May 19, 2016 @01:28PM (#11731919)
Does demanding efficiency of a business that is heavily subsidized and enjoys trade protectionism lead to economic decline?

No, because the state is eating the cost of that inefficiency. It's time for agriculture to be subject to market forces - they've enjoyed easy money like the banks for decades.

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by jedberg on Thursday May 19, 2016 @01:33PM (#11731958)
I actually agree with you, I think we need to get rid of the farm subsidies. I'm just saying the issue isn't so black and white that you can just demand the farms reduce their water usage.
Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by reality_czech on Friday May 20, 2016 @03:26AM (#11736059)
You could easily reduce agriculture water use by 10% just by banning the growth of super-thirsty crops like rice. The farmers would just shift to growing something else. And what orifice exactly did you pull "there is no impact to reducing residential water use" out of? There is certainly a huge inconvenience to residents, and it makes the state a much less desirable place to live.

Urban resident generate most of the revenue of the California government. Maybe we should get a say about how the state is run. And maybe we should not be lied to about who is using the state's water, and for what. Here's a clue: it's not restaurants serving glasses of water.

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by nickff on Thursday May 19, 2016 @01:26PM (#11731888)
Please avoid the broken windows fallacy.[1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by jedberg on Thursday May 19, 2016 @01:30PM (#11731941)
I'm well aware of the broken window fallacy and I didn't fall prey to it.

Unless you think every law forces a broken window fallacy. In which case, sure.

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by nickff on Thursday May 19, 2016 @01:36PM (#11732002)
Yes, you did.

>>>"If you reduce residential use by 25%, there is no impact to the economy -- actually there is a boost because of the increased revenues for landscapers and home improvement stores."

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by jedberg on Thursday May 19, 2016 @04:52PM (#11733741)
Actually no I didn't. There is in fact an increase in economic activity, there just isn't an increase in wealth. And I never said there would be.
Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by nickff on Thursday May 19, 2016 @05:51PM (#11734165)
This argument is addressed in the 'opportunity cost' section of the "Parable of the Broken Window" Wikipedia page.[1] Briefly, the economic activity is most apparent when spent replacing the broken window, while the opportunity costs are more diffuse, as that money may have been spend in small amounts on other things, but there is no overall increase in economic activity, only a transfer.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window#T...

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by Retric on Thursday May 19, 2016 @09:46AM (#11730102)
There is not a total separation between water underground and water in rivers. Streams can replenish the water table around them, or be replenished by the water table. Simply extracting as much water from the ground as you can will generally cost people 'downstream' water. In the long term there is only one source of natural fresh water, precipitation and it's finite abet renewable.

A great example of this is from Australia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Artesian_Basin People extracting water from hundreds of miles away end up drying up streams.

One viable option is simply to ban alfalfa or other high water use crops. No state constitutional issues with that.

PS: Globally, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artesian_aquifer are becoming very rare.

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by scurvy on Thursday May 19, 2016 @10:47AM (#11730627)
"I drink your milkshake" but water instead of oil.
Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by bradleyjg on Thursday May 19, 2016 @11:52AM (#11731117)
>> I don't see that happening right now, especially since it threatens several major industries in the state.

Can you quantify how major these industries are as a percentage of employment and/or state GDP?

Re:In Sharp Reversal, California Suspends Water Restrictions by dmoy on Thursday May 19, 2016 @01:30PM (#11731934)
Idk about the others, but ag is like 1.5-2% of CA GDP.