News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PG on trolls by Tichy on Saturday February 16, 2008 @07:17PM (#117217)
On news.yc it is not so extreme, but on german tech news site heise.de, there is also a modding system. Good threads become green, bad ones red. I have often wondered if people are more likely to start flaming away in the red threads. Sort of like beating up somebody who is already down on the floor (comments on the line of "you suck"). At heise.de I often had the impression that it is the case - not so much on news.yc, but it might be interesting to look at the statistics?
Re:PG on trolls by pg on Saturday February 16, 2008 @08:29PM (#117256)
News.YC users are definitely influenced by the prevailing trend, in both directions. I.e. people are more willing to vote something up as its score rises, and more prone to attack something as its score falls. It's not too bad yet here, but it got to be such a problem on Reddit that about a year ago they switched to not showing how many points a submission has till it's an hour old.
Re:PG on trolls by ced on Sunday February 17, 2008 @11:59AM (#117639)
Ever thought about doing a controlled experiment about it? I.e.: showing high points for a post to half the users, and low points to the other half.