I had the same reaction at first. But, then I was thinking about dogs; dogs evolve really quickly under pressure. If that's not a high pressure evolution event, I don't know what is.
I'm curious to read more about everyone in any event. Here's hoping.
It's not even about evolution. Imagine if the 7 eves weren't playing some weird genetic metagame, but instead had one over-arching problem to solve.
The main dilemma of the Pingers was how to survive underwater, and they had as much technology (if not more, there's more submarines in existence than ISS modules). They also had tons of food (think of how many whales died, and how long whale fall ecosystems last). And a nice natural shield consisting of the ocean.
If the Aidans could bring back the Neanderthal, then the Pingers probably started their experiments early and often.
The survival of both the other two groups seemed pretty far fetched to me.