IMHO, the "punch back firmly" attitude leads to reciprocation on both sides and a death spiral for any real dialogue.
As a culture, I believe that we are "punching back firmly" when it comes to vaccinations. California passed a law requiring vaccinations or a valid reason not to have one. Late-night comedy talk shows are mocking them. It sure as hell isn't polite, but measles isn't polite either.
I guess that I try to educate when I meet people in-person who are anti-GMO. The last anti-GMO person was a friend of the family at an engagement party-- I wasn't going to be mean about it. But I was firm and explained what kind of genes are moved over, and how it only changes a few things. And how that it's really cool that we're harnessing one piece of nature to help another piece of nature! I'll be aware to try persuasion over mocking.
This is a tangent, and I'm not a vegan, but you should be careful about conflating moral reasons with spiritual reasons. "I don't want to kill or cause the death of animals" is not a spiritual statement.
So, from their perspective, it is a science argument. Labeling their argument as anti-science is condescending in that it is received as a statement they are either not educated, have phobias of technology or their position comes from some religious or philosophical belief.
We also have to recognize that we often get things wrong and that's why in a free society people are free to choose what they consume and should have knowledge of what is in a product. http://www.investors.com/politics/capital-hill/how-settled-s...
The elephant in the room with vaccines is a credibility problem within the industry. Until that is addressed, doubt the dialog is going to improve. Whether the following are all true or not is irrelevant, these articles represent the lost of public trust which I believe is at the root of the problem that is never discussed.
https://www.lawyersandsettlements.com/articles/vioxx/vioxx-p...
At 6:30, mentions over 132,000 lawsuits filed against industry. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ch5OuzB9L48&feature=youtu.be...
Vaccines protected from lawsuits http://www.nvic.org/NVIC-Vaccine-News/March-2011/No-Pharma-L...
No, they are against all transgenic organisms. They are often quite fine with all the other existing lab-modified organisms.
Of course, this may be an awareness problem.
So to be more perfectly exact, let's go with: Transgenic crops.
I think that it's only in a few tech circles that being anti-GMO is immediately dismissed as anti-science. Living in Seattle, I run into a ton of anti-GMO people who don't have their false beliefs challenged. (And really, I can only do so much before I grow weary.)
The anti-GMO crowd takes a strong and extreme stance. They are against all lab-modified organisms! As someone with a biochemistry degree, I see that GM is a tool. Yes, it would be a bad idea to put proteins for peanut allergens into soybeans. Yes, the overuse of pesticides are a problem. (Although, GMOs probably use fewer pesticides: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/next/nature/fewer-pesticides-fa... )
From my perspective, it's the progressives that are hysterically lying about GMOs. So I punch back firmly! Most of these people don't have a solid understanding of the central dogma of biochemistry.
If we were more rational beings, we would observe that whether we should use GMOs or not is simply an engineering problem.