But you said, did you not, that Roundup - which is about 50% surfactants - was safe, safe to drink even. You compared it to drinking coffee IIRC. How is Roundup not toxic then?
People who work with it in fields should be careful. Consumers have a thousand other things more dangerous to worry about.
Safe when used properly.
>safe to drink even.
Never said that.
FWIW the context was ability to harm humans in any way; you were responding to a person saying they'd been given a rash after using Roundup.
>>"A good portion of which can do serious harm to life. Therefore "unknown" is the issue." (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11715508, goda90)
>"Your daily coffee is probably an order of magnitude more carcinogenic than any glyphosate/roundup exposure." (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11715557, searine)
Which I'll accept was not quite what I thought you'd said.
Will you admit that you've claimed roundup to be "incredibly safe"?
Also that in response to someone claiming it was harmful that your response, in context, suggested that coffee was more harmful?
He didn't say "more harmful", he said "more carcinogenic". That is a very specific form of harm.
It's perhaps strictly true, buy the manner is dishonest. Such an answer discredits the writer. The intent is to sow the idea that 'Roundup is less harmful to drink than coffee' even if the explicit expression was different.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15862083 "There is insufficient evidence to conclude that glyphosate preparations containing POEA are more toxic than those containing alternative surfactants"
Surfactants, in general, are toxic. There is nothing special about POEA. Used properly, surfactants can be of good use and result in safe improvement of agriculture.