Re:Ask HN: What are some rite-of-passage style projects for ...
by fao_ on Tuesday May 17, 2016 @07:24PM
(#11718460)
> and without it you'd just likely learn untrue things.
I prefer this to the more common 'Just don't do it', as you actually state why. The reason is something I knew intuitively but couldn't really (And had actually never devoted any time to) put[ting] it into words. Thank you.
For most types of problems, the feedback is clear - if it works and gives you the expected result, then it's (at least mostly) correct. For implementing cryptographic systems, a passing test suite doesn't mean anything, you'd need extensive expert review to tell you where you went totally wrong, and without it you'd just likely learn untrue things.