News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Urbanism by Mz on Friday March 05, 2010 @10:52PM (#1171123)
I don't think it's quite that simple.

I read a piece once called something like "A woman's place is in the city" which talked about how suburban sprawl is very much a bi-product of the traditional nuclear family with man as breadwinner, woman as homemaker, and 2.5 kids to raise. It only really works well for that social set up. If mom is not primarily a homemaker (with maybe a part-time job) who can shuttle the kids around, suburban sprawl is very isolating for kids -- or anyone else who doesn't drive/can't afford their own car (the poor, the elderly who can't safely drive anymore, etc). American demographics have changed and most "family units" no longer fit the nuclear family model. So suburban sprawl serves a great many Americans quite poorly, regardless of their opinions of cars or lawns.

MZ: wannabe urban-planner who got sidetracked along the way.

Re:New Urbanism by anamax on Saturday March 06, 2010 @12:32PM (#1171801)
> So suburban sprawl serves a great many Americans quite poorly, regardless of their opinions of cars or lawns.

True but irrelevant because no one said that suburban living was for everyone and suburbanists are happy to let folks make (and pay for) other choices.

It's the new urbanists who are pushing a "universal" vision.

As I wrote above, if something works only if everyone does the same, it probably doesn't actually work.